Page 129
He shrugged.
His curls were flatter today.
No bounce in them.
“We’re just different people,” he continued. “I went viral and you hate technology. You’d call the cops if someone was disturbing the public and I’d bring them beer and enough trash talk to make Mateo proud. You’d leave the sex toys in the closet; I’d steal them and throw them in a crab trap. I think there’s something nice about that—as two people, we don’t match. You brood, I project. You worry yourself into wrinkles, I earn mine by laughing. But there’s something about the two of us when we’re together that just works for me. We don’t fit into the same puzzle, but I think we still make a pretty damn good picture.”
Max’s entire demeanor changed.
From open to closed in a millisecond.
“But you don’t want a pretty picture. Not with me.”
There it was.
Simon didn’t get the chance to say he was wrong. Or to say he was right. To say he’d been trapped in his head for over a week, hating every second of it.
He didn’t get the time.
He didn’t deserve it.
And Max let him know that, just with different words.
“You lied to me,” he went on. “Donavon didn’t try to keep us apart. That was you. You said we would never happen. You told him that, and now? I think I agree with you. But I want to know why you think that’s true.”
Simon should have been ready for this.
He should have had his own prepared response, one that he’d rehearsed.
He wasn’t and he didn’t.
His words came out harsher than he meant them.
“I think we got caught up in the exact something that we both needed. We met after the man you would have married—had he asked—ended things and when I was in the middle of a move to a new life, away from a life that I realized I never really made a mark on.” He paused, trying to find a better way to say this, but continued, feeling his failure growing. “We never expected to see each other again after the restaurant, and then we were forced to work together every day. It’s been nice, but it hasn’t been real. Not the way it should be.”
Simon motioned to the room around them.
“Look at this place. We both need this, right? Us being together is only going to make what happens next harder.” He shook his head. “You want everyone to be happy, Max, and that is a fantastic thing to see in action, but… That’s too much pressure on the person trying their best to make sure you are also always happy. We need to stop this before it gets too serious. Before everything goes too far.”
Simon shouldn’t have said what he did next, but he knew it would do the trick.
“You’re looking for a leading love interest. I just want to be in the background. So, let me.”
And what a trick it was.
The damage was done in an instant.
Max’s hands dropped to his sides. His expression went blank.
For a second, Simon wasn’t sure he’d say anything, but if one thing rang absolutely true, it was that Maximiliano Hayes had a knack for knowing exactly what to say and when to say it.
“Because I’m tired of hearing it and want to set the record straight—”
He took a step closer to the desk and leaned over just enough that Simon’s heartbeat sped up from proximity.
“—I would have married Greg had he asked,” he continued. “I would have said yes and I would have walked down the aisle or gone to the courthouse or gotten Leon to dust off his officiant’s certificate he used for our cousin’s wedding. Because that’s what you do sometimes. You date someone that long, you run the risk of building up this idea of what’s supposed to happen. Most times, you assume it’s the same on the other side. But those feelings, those ideas, weren’t there on Greg’s side. And when he finally realized it, it was like he pulled the blindfold off of me, too. The anger, the anguish, the loudness you saw at the restaurant? It took me a while to realize, but that was just relief and regret. Mixing together while wearing new, fancy underwear.”
Max stood tall again. Simon kept his gaze.