AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Epicenter of Forever

Page 23

by Mara Williams

“How long have you been divorced?” The question comes at me while I’m on my tiptoes, reaching into an upper cabinet. I freeze, forcing my fingers to push the glass until it’s steady, and take a deep breath before answering. I want to tell him it’s none of his business, but I don’t want to reveal it matters to me.

“It was finalized a couple of weeks ago.” I keep my voice neutral.

“Is that something Nicolette forgot? Or did you forget to tell her?”

I turn, bracing myself for battle. This guy has a skill for using my anguish against me. “I didn’t want to worry her.” That’s not entirely true. And by the look on his face—narrowed eyes, chin raised—Caleb knows it.

“Well, she is worried. She talked about it the whole way home.”

I can’t do anything right with this guy. I’m a terrible daughter for hiding this from Mom. I’m a horrible person for upsetting her now. I don’t respond.

“Maybe you should let her know you’re fine. Anxiety can’t be good for her recovery.”

“Noted.” I’ll keep lying to her. That should be easy enough.

“But in case you’re not okay.” He unfolds his arms and wraps his hands around the counter ledge behind him. “It does get easier.”

“Thank you.” But what I want to say is Fuck you. Because what the hell does he know? Does betrayal ever get easier? I’d expect Caleb to be the last person to assure me that I’ll heal. He’s still judging me about how I failed to move on from the last deception that upended my life. I’m not exactly a poster child for forgiveness.

From what I hear, forgiveness is a precursor to healing. So I have a feeling this wound is going to fester. It is my superpower, after all.

“How long have you been divorced?” I ask, because knowledge is currency. I’m not giving this man anything he hasn’t given me.

“Officially? Five years.”

I do the math. The same math I did last week while looking at Nadia’s swollen torso. “Fiona is . . .” She told me she was four and a half. That doesn’t leave much space for the arithmetic of fidelity.

“Ian’s,” he confirms, although the genetics are apparent now that I’ve met him.

Maybe Caleb and I aren’t so different. Perhaps we can find some common ground.

“My husband . . .” I exhale and start again. “My ex-husband is having a baby. Any day now, actually.” How is it that his stern face and harsh assessments coax my confessions? Cassie would have some theories, I’m sure.

Caleb watches me, and there’s something about his stare that makes me think he can see right through me to my skin, bone, heart, hurt.

“Were you separated?”

I shake my head. “We separated eight months ago. I didn’t know at the time about the baby or the woman.” I laugh, although there’s nothing funny about it. And the way his body recoils in pity is even less funny. It’s secondhand embarrassment for my trauma.

“Yikes,” he says. “Is that why you’re so anxious to hide out here?”

I don’t know why I keep trying with this man. In my attempt at connection, I wind up pointing to my open wounds, so he knows where to pour the salt. I snap back, “Is your failed marriage why you’re so insistent on hanging around here, too?”

Caleb takes off his baseball cap and runs a hand through his haywire hair from back to front until he covers his face in one broad palm and sinks against the counter. “I didn’t mean that the way it sounded.”

“It sounded insensitive.” And I realize, I may not like Caleb all that much, but I do like myself in opposition to him and the fight he ignites. I like saying what I mean and telling him to fuck off when he deserves it. To hell with biting my tongue and keeping the peace. I did that with Jeff, and he left anyway. I swallowed my fury at Mom, and she left, too. “I already told you why I’m here, and I’m not putting up with your attitude while I put my life on hold to do what’s right. If you plan to be here, too, I suggest you get over whatever you have against me or keep it to yourself.”

“Okay.” Caleb raises his hands, palms up. But I’m not ready to accept his surrender.

“Because there was a good reason I never visited. There was a good reason I didn’t want to be here specifically—in this town, in this house. Being here isn’t easy for me. And I don’t need you making it harder. If you can’t do that, just stay away.”

He takes a cautious step closer. “Okay,” he repeats.

“You’ll stay away?”

Caleb shakes his head, slowly, as if he’s a hostage negotiator. Any minute now, I expect him to reach for my metaphorical gun. “I promised Sonny I’d take care of her. And Sonny and your mom were the only people who ever took care of me.”

And there it is again, the faintest vulnerability. I fight the urge to exploit it. As much as I like this new fight I’ve found, I take no pleasure in cruelty.