AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Other Side of Starting Over

Page 11

by Mara Williams

I take a deep breath, grateful that I remember how, even if the air is filled with lavender and lemon, like some cruel reminder of the way I humiliated myself earlier, of how good he smells up close. “Because my kids aren’t, and they need me to be fine.” If my parents are worried about me, hovering over me, that’s one more thing that’ll make the kids feel insecure.

Simon runs a hand through his hair, but it quickly falls back into place, a soft strand of black landing above one eye. I wish he would have been an elderly, sweater-vest-wearing Simon or a scrawny, graphic-T-shirt-wearing Simon. Why is he this Simon, with his lacerating stare and offensively long lashes?

I wonder how I must look to him. Hassled and broken, probably, my hair limp and too long, the violet depressions under my blue eyes I can’t seem to sleep away.

“As long as you’re fine, I don’t see any reason to say anything,” he says.

I’m not sure if that’s a promise or a warning, but I decide to feign ignorance, accept it as an oath, and hope he’s a man of his word. “Thank you.” I don’t look at him again, even though I feel his gaze on the side of my face while I slip out of the car. My skin is a heat map everywhere his eyes land.

“I guess I’ll see you tomorrow, boss.” The way he says boss, with grit on the deep B coming from the back of his throat, makes it sound dirty, even though it’s probably disrespect.

“I thought you had to ask my dad something.” I peer through the open window and immediately regret it. He’s chewing on his lower lip the same way he chewed on that pencil yesterday, like he has an oral fixation.

“I lied.” He backs out of the driveway, kicking up dust in his wake.

Chapter 5

The next morning, Mom makes good on her offer and shoves two sulking teens into her Outback. Destination: outlet mall. I hitch a ride to the shop with Dad to pick up my car but tell him I have a quick errand to run before getting started, which isn’t technically untrue but a lie, nonetheless.

Once he shuffles inside, I slide into my SUV and take a beat with my hands on the leather steering wheel, closing my eyes and inhaling. In my former life, this car was filled with carpools and chaos, the mess of meals devoured on the run, a cargo hold for sports equipment and camping gear. Now it’s the only space that’s truly mine. Being alone in here means I don’t have to regulate my emotions. For the twins’ sake, I’ve been wearing a neutral expression so dutifully that my face is bound to freeze that way, stoic and emotionless.

I shake out my shoulders as I start the car and pull out onto the street. There’s only one place I can look for Jake’s ghost—or time-traveling former self. I’m not sure I’m ready to revisit his childhood home, but I don’t have a choice.

Our towns are separated by a two-lane road that stretches around the perimeter of the lake, with the town of Suncrest situated on the east and Ponderosa Ridge on the west like opposite poles. There’s no innocuous reason for Faye to venture into Suncrest, because Ponderosa Ridge has more modern amenities—the bigger grocery store, fancier coffee shop, quicker access to the freeway. Her visit yesterday was premeditated and targeted.

I dissociate along the route because its curves and landmarks are an elegy I’m not ready to recite. The lake sparkles from outside the passenger window, poking out from behind pines. It’s the gem of the region—at least when it’s full. The last time we visited several years ago, the drought had starved it, made it shrivel until the waterline receded to reveal the gnarled roots and sediment along the bed. But it feasted on this year’s unseasonably wet winter, and now it rocks against the pine-strewn beach, satiated. It’s a wonder that the same season that stole my husband gave this land its soul back.

When I pull up in front of Faye’s, there’s an old Lincoln parked near the shed of the dilapidated house, and a Winnebago beside it. But Faye’s Jaguar is nowhere to be found. I wouldn’t put it past her to have rented the Jaguar for the day to make her grand entrance that much more dramatic.

I tiptoe up the steps, refusing to glance at the porch swing, where Jake first touched me with shaking hands and quivering breath, lifting the hem of my skirt, pushing aside the elastic of my underwear, and exploring me until we were both wide-eyed by the miracle of what our bodies could do.

I bang on the screen door and step back, hoping my heart palpitations don’t forecast another panic attack. I can guarantee Faye wouldn’t be nearly as gentle with me as Simon. When several moments pass, I knock again, unsettled by the rattle of the metal against the frame.

When the door swings open, my eyes struggle to adjust to the dark interior offset by the bright light of day. It’s his voice that hits me first, even though light travels faster than sound. Perhaps apparitions are governed by a different set of rules.

“May I help you?” Jake’s teenage ghost asks. It’s pitch perfect—the voice I last heard on a saved voicemail and have replayed a hundred times since.

It’s so clear and familiar that I wonder for a moment if perhaps it’s not his ghost standing before me, but instead I’ve teleported back in time so that we may begin again, do it all over, but right this time. I want to check a mirror to see if the years have been washed from my skin, too.

I stumble backward as he emerges from the dimly lit house, steps onto the porch, and holds the screen door ajar. I blink and grab the handrail, absorbing him in rapid camera shutters, my mind processing slower than it should, the width of his shoulders, the sandy hair, the cleft chin, and—

There’s a glitch in my system as I stare at the beautiful face I once memorized. There are details that don’t compute: blue eyes instead of brown, a height that Jake would have killed for, a narrower jawline, a right ear that doesn’t flare out just so.

“Ma’am?” he asks.

“Who are you?” I choke out.

He smiles tentatively, and it eviscerates me. It’s not Jake’s, exactly—it’s more tentative, less confident—but it’s close enough.

“If you’re looking for Faye, she’s not here,” he says with a nervous laugh.

My mind reels for an explanation, that Faye had a teenage son none of us knew about. I try to do the math and fail, my brain processing too many impossibilities to make room for mental arithmetic.

“Who are you?” I ask again, the glitch robbing my capacity for complex speech.

“Umm,” the kid says. “You came here knocking on my door. Who are you?”

Right now I don’t entirely know. A moment ago, I thought I was teenage Beatrice, sent through a time portal to reconnect with my back-from-the-dead husband and redo our love story from the beginning. But I’m not going to get anywhere if I tell him that.