The Other Side of Starting Over
Page 23
“September twentieth.”
“You’re turning how old?”
“Nineteen.”
I try to do the mental math in my head. But I’m too emotional to figure it out right now.
“Did Faye put you up to this?”
“Did Faye what?” His lip curls. “I don’t know what you’re accusing me of.”
“I’m not accusing you of anything, but I don’t trust Faye. I trust facts. I need to find out for sure before . . .” I consider telling the kids and shattering their world again. “Would you be open to a paternity test?”
He looks up from his ice cream, a scowl on his familiar face. “Why should I trust you?”
“The truth is a win-win, right?”
Assuming River is Jake’s kid based on resemblance alone is a leap. Another possibility unfurls before me, a possibility that could absolve Jake entirely. I wouldn’t put it past Faye to have abandoned another kid, a boy who fathered River and took off.
The more nefarious explanation is that River is a look-alike Faye found somewhere, and River was in on the plan to extort Jake. But somehow, seeing this kid, his fragility and fear, I don’t think so.
“What if Faye has another son that she’s not telling us about? You could be his son.”
“My dad was Jake.” He stares me down, setting aside his ice cream, almost like he’s pushing me—and my cheap peace offering—away.
“If you thought Jake was your dad, why didn’t you reach out to him? Why are you here with Faye?”
River bounces his knee and blinks in triplicate. “I was looking for Jake Dolion from Ponderosa Ridge. That’s all I knew about him.”
Jake Dolion would be hard to find.
One of Jake’s biggest romantic gestures was taking my name when we married. Jake Bell was determined to erase every last tie to his familial shame. It’s yet another thing Faye has held against me.
“Instead, you tracked down Faye?” I backtrack to when Jake’s strange behavior started. “I’m guessing that was about a year ago, right?”
He nods. “I couldn’t find my dad. But it’s a small town, and it’s an unusual last name.”
The only way I can combat his distrust is with logic. “But once you found Faye, instead of giving you Jake’s number, she called him directly, is that right?”
He swallows, darts his eyes to the side, and it’s close enough to an admission.
“You don’t know what she told Jake or what he said to her? You only have her word for it,” I say. It’s a guess, but one based on patterns. Faye will take every opportunity to hoard information to manipulate anyone, even her own son.
“But she’s my grandmother,” he says.
“Who you didn’t meet until recently.”
“I’ve known her longer than I’ve known you.” He bounces his knee again, and I think I’m getting through to him. Or perhaps I got through to him the other day, and that’s exactly why he showed up at the shop.
“That’s why we need proof. Then it’s not about who’s lying or who’s telling the truth; it’s about facts.”
“And what are you gonna do if we prove he was my dad?”
His gaze skates across me, but his expression is softer, more vulnerable.
“I guess . . .” I pause because I have no idea. I have made too many decisions in the last several months, all of them destined to impact Tess and Miles in ways I can’t foresee. “We’ll get to know each other better. And then I’ll see if it’s a good idea for you to meet my kids. They’ve been through a lot of pain and change, and I need to be careful—”
“You think I’d be a bad influence or something?” He straightens his shoulders.