AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Other Side of Starting Over

Page 43

by Mara Williams

“To protect them, yes.”

“For eighteen years?”

Which is about how long Jake probably lied to me.

“So, then your mom finally told you about him recently?” I’m pretty sure River would have been born while Jake and I were away at separate colleges. We took a break before we left for school, thinking the distance would make it too difficult. But we reunited by the Thanksgiving break, both home for the long weekend, and quickly fell back into each other’s arms. Jake swore he hadn’t touched another girl, too busy pining for me. But the timing of our short break doesn’t align to absolve him anyway. River would have been conceived later—our sophomore year, I think. I need to face the fact that if we confirm River is his son, it means Jake was unfaithful, and if Jake cheated on me while we were dating, what does that say about his fidelity, integrity, or allegiance to our marriage?

But I’m not sure it even matters now. Jake is dead, and he can’t answer my questions.

River stands abruptly, brushing his hands on his jeans. “Text me when you know, all right?”

I stand, too, as if etiquette requires it, as if there is proper etiquette at the conclusion of a paternity test on the possible son of your dead husband.

River turns toward the sound of approaching footsteps. I follow his gaze to a couple emerging from the main trailhead. It’s the boots that catch my attention. Combat boots are an odd choice for a morning hike, but I would expect nothing less from Simon. Then I track his companion, a fit woman decked out in athleisure with a flouncy copper ponytail. I clock the moment Simon sees me because his face goes from animated to blank. They’re about ten yards away, but we’re the only four people at the lake this early, so politeness demands something—a wave, a hello, a brief conversation about the weather—and yet Simon and I just stare at each other.

“I’m gonna take off,” River says, and I say goodbye, which snaps me out of it, reminding me that locking eyes with a colleague across a picnic area is not normal behavior. River heads toward the parking lot, jiggling his keys.

I hold my hand up in a wave, and Simon returns it, unfurling a palm in a tepid greeting, and I think that’ll be it. We’ll leave each other to our separate worlds, but the woman with him nudges him forward, and his boots kick up dust on his way over.

“Hey.” Simon shoves his hands in his pockets.

“Hi.” My smile is forced, and I’m not sure why I feel weird about seeing Simon in the wild. We made peace. We had a constructive conversation. We almost got each other off in a half-dream state. Perhaps we aren’t friends, but we’re a few degrees north of foes now.

“I’m Chloe,” his stunning hiking buddy says, extending her hand. Her smile is wide, and she has adorable dimples and the most beautiful hazel eyes.

“Beatrice.” I take her hand. “Simon and I work together.”

“Oh?” Chloe looks between us, and something passes across her face I can’t read. I wonder if Simon has complained about me, or if he’s not mentioned me at all. I’m not sure which scenario bothers me more.

The shop is closed on Mondays, so it shouldn’t matter what Simon does on his day off. But there’s only one reason for them to be hiking at daybreak—they must have spent the night together. If that’s what he meant by “dating sometimes,” he probably shouldn’t have been sharing a bed with me as a heat-seeking octopus. Perhaps that makes me a prude, but I’m a little sensitive about commitment and honesty these days. To be fair, maybe their situationship isn’t defined. But if I were to picture him with a woman, which I’m trying hard not to, it wouldn’t be this ray of lululemon sunshine.

Now that introductions are made, and Simon and Chloe haven’t wandered off, I’m at a loss as to what to say next.

“How long have you worked at the antique store?” Chloe asks, and there it is again, that subtle, unreadable thing, as she flicks a glance at Simon.

“She owns it,” Simon says.

“Oh.” Chloe smiles at Simon, showing teeth that are Hollywood straight and have never touched coffee or red wine, but there’s something brittle in her expression. “I thought the owners were about to retire.”

“Those are my parents. I just moved back into town.” I adjust the box under my arm and dig into my purse for my keys. “I should head out.”

“Nice to meet you,” Chloe says.

“You too.” I try to catch Simon’s eye, but his chin is turned, and he’s staring over the lake. “See you tomorrow, Simon.”

I’m walking away before I hear his unintelligible reply; his discomfort at this collision couldn’t be clearer. And it’s not hard to imagine why. Perhaps he didn’t tell her about the night he spent marooned in a motel room with his coworker or that he knows what my ass feels like in his palms. Perhaps he didn’t want me to know this part of his personal life. Well, I didn’t want to know it either. Boundaries. That’s what we need.

I shouldn’t look back, but as I start my car, I spy Chloe reaching over to hug Simon, and my heart pinches at the way he softens, wrapping his long arms around her back and tucking her head under his chin. They seem to sway in the breeze as I flee the scene, rubbing a tender spot on my chest.

I almost remember what it felt like to be held like that.

Almost.

Chapter 19

I package up the swab and the hair from Jake’s brush, careful to include follicles with the root attached, and head to the post office. The clock begins ticking in my head the moment I mail the kit, and the second hand strokes a drumbeat against my skull. Two weeks until I must face the truth, whatever it may be. I’ve never been good at waiting for news. The worst thing someone can say to me is We need to talk. Are you free next week? I’d rather the certainty of bad news than worry about the possibility of terrible news, and waiting for these results will test my tenuous patience.

When I get home, the house is eerily quiet. I find a note on the dining room table from my parents that they’ve gone into town to run errands, and the twins are still sleeping. I knock on Miles’s door and find them both. We gave them their own rooms when they turned five, but most mornings, we’d find them together, feet to head and head to feet, like yin and yang.