AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Other Side of Starting Over

Page 56

by Mara Williams

Simon’s eyes make a circuit of my face. “You even have good ideas for an overeducated MBA.”

I can’t help but laugh, and it feels cathartic. “Hello? I’m in a life crisis. You need to be nice to me.”

Simon waves to the serene scene as if it is exhibit A of his chivalry. “I’m so nice to you, you don’t know how to deal with it. Sit.” He slides in beside me on the park bench and pours two shots. “I don’t think your dad will mind us stealing his liquor, under the circumstances.”

We lift our glasses and toast, which is ridiculous in the moment but feels right somehow. A toast to the truth. A toast to the wait being over. A toast to my dad storing whiskey in his office so I can deaden my stage fright while starring in my personal trashy talk show.

I throw back the shot and wince as it burns my throat. The last time I tasted whiskey was on Jake’s lips, but I chase away the thought because the blistering sting is heady and freeing. It’s a relief to feel something more potent than my panic.

“What if the results are inconclusive?” I say aloud, realizing that the wait may not be over. There’s a not-insignificant chance that the hair wasn’t usable, that I didn’t salvage the roots, or that the sample was too old. I may have to talk to the twins and swab Miles’s cheek—starting the countdown all over again, but this time with the twins waiting and worrying alongside me.

“Then you’re no worse off than you are now.”

“Maybe I need another shot—or three.”

Simon dutifully pours me three fingers of liquid courage. I down it, coughing as I come up for air, and immediately grab my phone to scroll to the email, fighting the impulse to squeeze my eyes shut and hum over the ringing in my ears.

Instead, I let my gaze dart across the screen, too amped up to digest the words. I take a breath, blink, and start again.

I’m grateful that my limbs are already tingling from the whiskey when I get to the bottom of the screen and freeze on the final line: The probability of paternity is 99.9%.

I set my phone on the bench between us and throw my head back, letting the numbing effect of the alcohol overpower my body’s instinct to tense up to protect me. A 99.9 percent probability is even too much for my wild card theory that River was the son of some child Faye abandoned. Jake is River’s father. Not his uncle. Not a coincidental doppelgänger. There’s no denying this result.

I was still holding out hope that River was lying or mistaken, and the confirmation hurts more than I imagined. Preparing for the worst does not make the worst any less traumatizing. I can’t find words that are strong enough for my emotional collapse, so silence fills the air like a third guest.

Simon doesn’t move, doesn’t ask. He lets me sit in the knowing, in all its brutality and relief, its implausibility and inevitability.

As the panic creeps in, I pattern my breathing after his, sensing the vibrations against the bench, regulating my body temperature through his. After a few moments, I sense his rough hand grasping mine. I’m an object in motion, and Simon is friction. The sandpaper grit of his fingertips presses into my knuckles, giving me something more solid to hold on to than the slippery slope of my memories.

The call-and-response of crickets coaxes me into my body. I open my eyes to the incandescent glow of hundreds of fractured crystals hanging from an oak whose canopy I watched grow and expand as a child—and to Simon, who is studying me with an expression as soft as it is typically severe.

“I don’t know how to tell my kids,” I say.

“There’s no shame in the truth.” Simon speaks slowly, in harmony with the night chorus. “And it’s not your mistake to answer for.”

“But Jake’s not here to answer for it.” It’s poetic that he left me to do the dirty work one last time. He was the fun parent, the let’s-go-out-for-ice-cream parent, the let’s-camp-in-the-backyard parent, and the let’s-go-to-Disneyland parent. I didn’t mind it then. But now my resentment festers like an ignored wound. “They adored him. I don’t want them to hate their father, but I also don’t want them to think what he did was okay. Tess might learn to distrust men, and Miles could learn that cheating is okay, or . . .” I sigh. “What if they think less of me, that I was a doormat?”

“If there’s one thing I’m sure of, it’s that you are no doormat.”

I don’t know whether that’s a dig or a compliment. I risk a glance in Simon’s direction. His eyes are bottomless, sunken in shadow, but his soft mouth is in the foreground, highlighted by the warm glow.

“This is your mess to deal with, but not to apologize for,” he says.

“I’m a mother of teens. All I do is apologize, whether it’s my fault or not.”

“Maybe you should stop doing that.” Simon gives my hand another pulse, and it’s CPR on my nervous system, keeping me from a full-blown breakdown.

I thought I was prepared for the truth, but I’ve been clinging to a hologram of the man I loved. The one who would run out to the store at midnight if I had a craving for chocolate, who picked up Tess from school and took her to the mall when her crush broke her heart, who lay on the floor for hours to build LEGO sets with Miles, who gave me foot massages like it was his calling.

But there’s no erasing DNA evidence of his betrayal.

How could those two men be the same person?

“This wasn’t the love story I wanted.” It’s painful to disavow it. He was all my love stories.

I stare at the lavender growing in the claw-foot tub, resting against the lattice fence. The purple flowers are luminous in the glow of the chandeliers. The beauty is stark against the new ugly reality of my life.

Simon drags his thumb across the back of my hand and lets the crickets weigh in. A breeze picks up, tickling a collection of wind chimes. It’s a while before he speaks. “In my experience, we don’t get to write much of our own story. At least not the turning points.”