The Other Side of Starting Over
Page 80
He laughs. “I love finding them, refurbishing them, and sending them off. But I prefer to live with little,” Simon says. “If I brought the work home, I’d never be off the clock.” He opens the fridge and grabs a few bags of produce before digging around for something else.
“I feel that. My parents’ house—”
He pops his head out. “Would give me hives.”
I laugh, leaning my elbows on the counter.
“Don’t get me wrong,” he says. “It’s beautiful, but I’d be drawn to repair every ding and tempted to sell before I ruined one of the pieces. When I’m at home, I want to—”
“Breathe.”
“Exactly.” He inhales to demonstrate, and I can’t help but mimic him. “Besides, my grandparents had a lot of valuables, but they were robbed of everything when I was here one summer. It made me hesitant to keep anything of value. These lakeside homes are a magnet for thieves.”
Shit.
The memory dislodges. I know why this house looked familiar. Jake pointed it out to me as one of the homes his mom robbed with his help. He befriended a couple of boys on vacation to scope it out in advance. Faye has left an indelible mark on this lake, and so did Jake. I’m thrown that Jake and Simon must have known each other, at least briefly. But that’s not a memory lane I want to invite Simon to join me on.
I imagine Simon, Elias, and Jake as boys. As friends. Or some version of it. It means Jake’s been here. In this house. I shiver as if I’m walking through his spirit, and I wish I could exorcise him. I don’t want any part of Jake here. Not his demons or his secrets or his lies. Not tonight.
I turn away, wandering over to the glass wall to take in the unobstructed view in the evening light. The lake is placid against the subsiding winds, and a lone speedboat cuts through the shimmering surface. Outside, there’s a generous redwood deck with a staircase down to a dock. A kayak is propped on top, and a small skiff jostles against it.
We’re on the east side of the lake, and I can see a hint of the sunset we’ll be invited to watch soon. This view has a way of making the world appear, if not kinder, then less cruel, maybe, as if all tragedy is unintentional; it calls us to make the best of what’s offered. It demands we see possibilities instead of catastrophes.
I startle when Simon strides up beside me, his hands in his pockets and his scent wrapping around me like ivy.
He studies my profile. “You’re smiling.”
“I do smile sometimes.” But I force my mouth into a straight line, self-conscious now that he’s called me out.
“Politely at customers, sure. Indulgently at your kids. But rarely just because.”
I shrug. “It’s been a good day, and I can’t remember the last time I had one of those.”
He hums. “And hopefully I can make it even better.”
I startle out a laugh, my eyes widening at his innuendo.
“With dinner,” Simon stammers. “I’m talking about dinner. I want to feed you something you’ll enjoy.”
His bumbling makes me laugh harder. “I’m sure I’ll like anything you make.”
He raises a brow. “Really? Because I’ve seen you eat about two things. You’re picky.”
My appetite has been as depressed as the rest of me, but picky I am not. “I think you don’t know me that well, then.”
He hums again, and I can almost feel the vibration. “Not true.”
I laugh because if I don’t, I may succumb to the sound and move closer to investigate its texture. He’s irresistible tonight in an olive T-shirt that makes his skin look silken. The descending sun highlights his sharp cheekbones and soft mouth, reminding me that I know what it feels like against my skin. “You think you know me?”
He watches me for a moment, as if deciding whether or not to answer. “I know you have a scar behind your left ear.” Simon points to it before tucking his hand into his pocket. “I know that you must straighten your hair because your curls sneak out at the end of a warm day. I know your blue eyes look too vivid to be real, but you got them from your dad and gave them to your son, and they look best on you.” His smile is wistful and disappears so quickly that I’m tempted to chase it. “I know that you’re incredibly loyal and sometimes give more than people give you back. You’re careful and risk averse, and don’t make a decision without interrogating it to death first.” He glances at the lake, pausing for a moment before meeting my eye again. “I think trust comes naturally to you, actually, but it’s been broken, so you’re trying to silence your instincts. I know you’re the most patient mother I’ve ever met, and that your kids adore you right back, even if they’re too hurt and cool to show it right now.”
I don’t think I’ve ever had someone read me so generously, and I’m a sucker for his compliments and kindness. He’s watching me for my reaction—or maybe studying my soul. I worry he sees my heart beating out of my chest and the pulse point in my neck betraying me, waving the white flag of my resistance.
I have to swallow a swell of emotion to speak. “Well, maybe I don’t know you all that well, then.”
“What do you want to know?” he asks, so simple, as if he hasn’t been infuriatingly evasive since we met.
“Oh, now you’re willing to answer my questions?”