The Other Side of Starting Over
Page 86
Simon won’t let me leave hungry.
“I can’t have you passing out.” He forces me to wait on a stool while he makes two irresistible sandwiches from buttered sourdough, cheddar, and Gruyère. It isn’t the meal he’d planned before I dragged him to bed, but it is perfection. I devour it in a handful of bites while he waits patiently for his to cool. He’s given me my appetite back.
When I finally peel myself away, he walks me to my car and kisses me good night, pressing me against the side of my SUV with his hands in my damp hair.
“Returned to factory settings,” Simon hums as he twists a lock of my hair in his index finger, spiraling it until it springs against my neck. “Why do you straighten it?”
I run my fingers through the damp curls. “I don’t, really. I brush and go. And don’t cut it often enough, so it’s not curly, not straight, until the humidity takes control.”
“I like it.”
“I like you,” I say.
He smiles against my mouth as I give him a final kiss and slide into the driver’s seat.
The kids are still at the party, so I’m hopeful I can beat them home and catch them before they sneak off to bed. But as I drive by Main Street, my curiosity snags on my earlier fixation, and I pull off at the store. I can’t believe I was preoccupied and happy enough to forget about the iPad—and Jake’s secrets—waiting for me at Bygones.
When I go inside, I grab Jake’s fully charged tablet but resist the temptation to check it here. I lock back up and head down the street to Cream and Cone to grab two pints of mint chip and salted caramel. Perhaps a late-night treat will entice the twins to open up about their evening.
Twenty minutes later, I’m waiting for them in the sitting room when headlights flash through the front windows.
“Oh, hey, Mom. I thought you’d be asleep.” Tess walks into the house and gives me a hug, and I might collapse in relief from the unsolicited affection.
“How was it?” I ask instead of babbling. I missed you, I love you, please don’t ever freeze me out again.
“It was pretty good, actually. The place was super nice. I’ve never seen anywhere that fancy in Suncrest before.”
Miles slinks in with my parents but zigzags around us, heading to his room.
“Hey, sweetheart.” I stop him with my hand on his wrist. “Did you have fun?”
“It was all right, I guess.”
“It was a beautiful party, Bea. The kids met so many nice young people,” Mom says.
“I picked up ice cream. Do you guys want some?”
“I just had cake,” Miles says.
“Sorry, Bea. We’re beat,” Dad says. “Thanks for letting us borrow the kids for the night.”
Tess steps back, moving toward her room. “I have to call Sophia. Aiden broke up with her, and she’s freaking out.” Tess releases me. “Also, she told me Ms. Louise has been trying to call you, and you keep ignoring her.”
“I’m not ignoring her.” Although that’s not entirely true. My life back in the Bay Area seems like it happened a million years ago, and my friendships are bound to a faded version of me I don’t know anymore. Louise, Naya, and their families were linked to my marriage: Friday-night pizza, evenings with wine around the firepit, Sunday swims, and weekend getaways. I don’t know how to talk to them about my new reality: River, Simon, living at home with my parents. And if I can’t share the real stuff, I don’t want to share anything. “Our schedules are off.”
“Well, you should call her tomorrow. Sophia said she seemed kinda hurt about it.”
Within five minutes, the house is quiet with everyone squirreled away to their private spaces. So much for ice cream bonding and details about their night.
After I shower and head upstairs, I settle into bed, my mind spinning. I left Simon only an hour ago, but it already feels like a dream. Did I really sleep with him and skinny-dip in Suncrest Lake? I could convince myself I imagined it if my skin wasn’t still tender from his touch. I’m living in a surreal world, caught between two men I don’t actually know all that well. Simon’s unknowns are encased in a treasure chest I hope to open over time.
Jake’s unknowns are buried in Pandora’s box.
I stare at his iPad, my need to know at war with my fear. Digging into Jake’s private messages may make us even more estranged. But I need answers more than the solace of ignorance. I touch it awake, squeeze my eyes shut until I see stars behind my lids, and count to three.
Chapter 36
Opening my message thread with Jake picks at a newly formed scab. There’s a photo of Tess and Miles at the beach in Santa Cruz last summer, mundane notes about schedules and grocery lists, my irritation at him for missing a pickup from soccer practice. It’s a portrait of another time, when I was too cavalier about Jake’s mortality, when I should have begged him to keep himself safe, when I should have been demanding answers about his erratic behavior instead of nitpicking about the frustrating impact.