AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Other Side of Starting Over

Page 89

by Mara Williams

“At eight in the morning on Sunday?” I take a swig of my coffee. My dad makes it battery-acid strong, which is exactly how I like it.

He nods. “We’re getting Starbucks and checking out the new skate shop and then seeing the matinee because it’s cheaper.”

“Which friends are these?”

He chews and swallows a mouthful of Cheerios. “Josh and Ryan.”

“Leave their numbers so I have them in case there’s an emergency.” He nods. “I’m heading out that way; I can take you.”

“Where are you going?” He brings his bowl to the sink, rinses it, and places it in the dishwasher. He’d never do that at home without being nagged. I’m pleased with his manners but worried he feels like a guest here, and it’s the only home he has.

“The nursery.” I bury this big secret in a truth.

Miles is quiet and fidgety on the way, and I’m too overwhelmed to force conversation with a recalcitrant teen. “You can play music if you want.”

Miles chooses some new generic pop song. If we were playing Jake’s Name That Tune quiz, I would fail.

When I pull up in front of the Starbucks, Miles hops out and closes the door without saying goodbye.

“Hey,” I call through the open window.

He turns back, expectant.

“Bye.” I try to keep the irritation out of my voice. I’ve made progress with Tess, but Miles is still holding me at a distance. I don’t want to push him farther away.

“Oh, yeah. Bye.”

“Have fun. Be safe.”

River is busy helping a customer when I arrive. I pretend to check out the native flowers on display, feigning interest until I’ve circled the flower beds three times. Finally, I settle at a park bench under a magnolia tree and pull out my phone.

When I see Simon’s name, my stomach flips in excitement and unease. The memory of last night is a fever dream. Discovering more truths about Jake’s motivations and actions shouldn’t change how I feel about Simon. Jake is gone. He lied to me. But context is everything, and knowing Jake intended to tell me, claim River, and try to make it right makes the timing of his loss even more cruel. It suggests he wasn’t a monster, just a flawed man. And it confirms I’ll never be over losing him.

I’m furious at Jake, but that doesn’t neutralize the love. It also doesn’t eliminate my feelings for Simon or the hope and happiness I feel with him.

Simon was clear he didn’t want to touch me if there was another man in my head. But what if another man will forever be in my heart?

Simon: ​​Hi, beautiful. I can’t stop thinking about last night. I’ll call you as soon as I’m back in town.​​

I’m too keyed up and confused to respond. But perhaps it’s good that he’ll be gone for a bit, so I can process all this new information.

I startle when River sits beside me. He removes his gardening gloves, placing them in his lap before he brushes his hair off his forehead. His resemblance to Jake stabs me in the solar plexus. Genetics are generous and ruthless.

“I swear if you’re putting off letting me meet the kids again—”

“I’m not.” I swallow. “I have to show you something. And it might be upsetting. Is there somewhere we can go?”

River glances around the nursery, almost empty this morning. “Here’s fine.”

I pull out the iPad and scroll to the text thread. “I think your dad”—I pause, tasting that word on my tongue—“deleted the text messages he exchanged with Faye after she told him about you. But he didn’t realize he would need to delete them from every device. I found their conversation on this iPad last night.”

His expression is skeptical. “How’s that gonna help me?”

“Jake wanted to meet you. Faye told him you refused.”

River’s face contorts and twists into disbelief, and I study him at the off chance he’s playing me, too. I don’t want to be blinded by his relation to Jake and overlook his relation to Faye. He could have been in on the extortion, but I remember the way Faye tried to cover in front of him, the way she put on the sweet-granny act when I confronted them at her house. I thought she was hiding something from him. Now I know what it was.

“She wouldn’t do that. She knew how much I wanted to meet him.”