The Other Side of Starting Over
Page 97
“You can’t know that.”
“But I believe it.”
I glare at him in the dim light, watching his face for signs I must have missed—of his duplicity and faithlessness. Does he feel guilty for cheating on Chloe and lying to me? I can’t imagine what he told her to get out of their romantic weekend or how he lives with himself after sleeping with me at my most vulnerable and showing up at the most terrifying moment in my life under the guise of compassion. “Your belief system doesn’t mean much to me, Simon. You should go back to Chloe and leave us the hell alone. I can’t deal with you when I’m dealing with this.”
Simon sucks in a breath, and it’s the most affected I’ve ever seen him. I must have landed a punch. Good. I’m relieved it’s all out in the open, because now we can end this farce immediately. I’m incapable of pretending or fighting this out with him.
“Deal with me?” Simon feigns confusion with a frown. “Go back to Chloe? You knew where I was?”
“Please leave.” I don’t have the emotional energy for the rage he deserves.
He opens his mouth, closes it, sighs, and crosses his arms. His focus on me is too heavy. It might make me collapse on the porch as I wait for Miles to return and for life to make sense again. I need Simon to leave me to my vigil.
“I can’t fathom what you’re going through, Beatrice. But I’m confused. You seem angry at me, specifically. If you knew where I was, you must know it means a lot that I left.”
I snort, a derisive, ugly sound, and it’s too close to a cry, which I can’t lose myself to right now.
“I want to be here for you.” Simon steps closer, reaching out a hand. I tense up and he drops it.
“Are you trying to tell me you left Chloe for me? Because you really shouldn’t have.”
Simon studies me as if memorizing my face might give him the key to his redemption.
“Leave Chloe?” Simon shakes his head and then speaks slowly and calmly, like he’s reading aloud to a child. “I was meeting my parents, Chloe, and a few friends. But they all understood why I flew back. I’m beginning to think you don’t, though.”
I need him to go, to get the fuck off my porch and out of my line of sight. I have to bolster myself against anything superfluous to Miles’s safe return. “I know you were meeting her at a B&B. And I saw the photos she sent you today—your engagement shots, bikini photos, beach vacations? If you were going to lie to me about her, you really should have deleted your texts from the work tablet. Why are cheaters so shitty at covering their tracks?”
Simon sucks in a breath and covers his face in his hands, and I step toward the front door. Maybe I can lock him out. But as I twist the knob, Simon’s voice freezes me in place.
“Chloe was engaged to Elias, not me.”
“I saw you, Simon. I saw the photos.” But I’m not nearly as confident now.
“You saw my brother, Beatrice. We were identical.”
The sound of the moth against the light mimics the rapid-fire beat of my heart. That can’t be true. Simon and Elias were twins? He never told me that. Why would he not tell me that? Why tell me now, of all moments? When I can’t know this, not with Miles in danger, not with Tess’s twin out there in the world walking around with the other half of her heart. My babies will not survive without the other. And Simon . . .
I try to swallow, but I almost choke on the ball in my throat. “You didn’t ever say—”
“When I found out Tess and Miles were twins”—he steps closer, and the porch creaks in his wake—“I wasn’t trying to hide it, exactly, but I know how hard secondhand trauma is when you’re already grieving. I thought it might hit too close to home for you, and I didn’t want to put something in your head that losing a twin was—”
“Possible,” I finish. Because it isn’t possible, it can’t be. Twins should never lose each other. Tess and Miles can’t lose each other. Their souls are knitted together in spun gold. I have an ultrasound photo of them holding hands. Miles would suck Tess’s thumb as a newborn. They’d sleep like yin and yang in the crib. As toddlers, they understood each other’s gibberish and were slow to speak in a language anyone else could comprehend. There isn’t a world in which Tess would survive, in which I would survive if Miles . . .
How does Simon stay upright after losing his Miles? How did he survive that hurt?
It makes no sense that I’m still standing here, still breathing, still talking, still alive while Miles is out there somewhere, at the mercy of a woman without a conscience.
“When you met Chloe a few weeks ago, she was visiting to share that her boyfriend proposed. She wanted to tell me in person because she thought it might be tough for me. And it was, even though it shouldn’t have been. It’s just that we’d mourned together and now she’s moving on, and . . .”
“Simon,” I say, because I can’t find any other words. I feel like I might collapse under the weight of our shared pain.
“And this weekend . . . tomorrow is the five-year anniversary of Elias’s death,” Simon says. “My parents, Chloe, and our friends . . . we were all meeting in Seattle to”—he pauses, swallows—“honor the anniversary and be together.”
“And you turned around.” The words catch in my throat.
“I got a message from Javier as soon as I landed and immediately hopped on a flight home.” His voice grows soft. “I couldn’t save my brother. But I had to help save your boy.”
I’ve stayed strong, or maybe numb, for hours, but I lose it now, the sobs tearing through my body like a squall. I don’t register Simon’s arms coming around me until I almost fall to the floor, and he scoops me up, holding my bones together as my soul escapes.