Page 10
It started when she no-showed at one of his concerts she’d promised to attend.
“He was slayed,” our source said. “He had to walk onto the stage knowing she picked something—or someone—over him.”
Then came the whispers of late-night arguments, separate hotel rooms, and canceled vacations. The lack of public appearances was noticeable. Those closest to the couple bit their lips in the beginning, but said the writing was on the wall.
But the biggest accusation?
One person close to the band reported, “Right before the storm hit, there were already rumors about the steamy relationship even Hollywood couldn’t produce, and Effie’s carefully timed exit to stage left. She got out first so she could control her image.”
And control it she did.
Within days of the split, public sympathy leaned heavily in her favor while Phoenix was painted, once again, as the reckless rockstar with too much ego and not enough restraint.
Another insider insisted that version of the story was very, very wrong. “Effie needed to toughen up her image. She was tired of the lovey-dovey roles she was being offered. She had her sights set on the golden statue. And for that, she needed to step into edgier, suspenseful, and yes, even pearl-clutching roles. Phoenix Vale was the dark to her light. The tattoo to her untouched skin. And little white lines to her Bible study.”
But the most telling fact our sources reported? “He loved her, and she used him.”
Ouch.
Vale is reportedly pouring his broken heart into the next Night Theory album, which sources say may be his most personal—and brutal—record yet.
“Phoenix writes from pain,” a music insider said. “If Effie broke his heart, everyone’s about to hear exactly what that felt like.”
Meanwhile, Effie has vanished from Los Angeles, and the press keeps circling.
Convenient timing or strategic retreat? Everyone in Hollywood knows the best way to sweep a story under the rug is to say nothing and not feed it.
But someone is speaking, which adds fuel to the fire. Phoenix recently posted a cryptic late-night message on social media that fans were quick to interpret:
Some want love.
Some want applause.
Subtle?
Not even a little.
Neither star has officially commented ... yet. But you know me. If anyone can get to the bottom of a dramatic story, it’s Portia LaRue.
And if insiders are right, lovies, the fairy-tale romance between Phoenix Vale and Effie Devaux may not have begun with starry-eyed love—but with ambition.
Stay with The Fifth for continuing coverage.
CHAPTER FOUR
HOW MANY ISSUES DO YOU HAVE?
Effie
Elise Hart has been my publicist for years. Until now, she’s the biggest waste of money I’ve spent since I started acting.
Back in the day, Greer insisted I hire her after my first breakout role. “You don’t need a publicist until life shits all over your career, pookie. Anyone in this industry who thinks they’re immune to said shit is as much of an imbecile as ninety percent of the population when it comes to the state of their skin barrier.”
Aside from adding another one of Greer’s skincare analogies to the list, she’s right about one thing—life eventually shit on me, and it did it in epic fashion.
At least, I’m finally getting my money’s worth out of my publicist.
Elise does everything she can to calm me down from her LA office. “I know it looks bad, Effie, but as I always say, breathe first, burn them later. In this case, I may need to send you an oxygen tank. Goodness knows, you probably need it up in those mountains.”