Page 89
“Keep living?”
I nod, chewing on the inside of my cheek.
“Oh, Ches.” His expression softens as he sets his beer down. “It destroyed me. I just couldn’t let it.”
It feels like I’m a little boy again, looking to my older brother for advice. Like I’m small, and he’s smart and knows how to handle everything better than me.
“You were sixteen,” he says, smiling sadly. “You stopped eating. You weren’t sleeping, and when you did, the nightmares came. I saw the way you blamed yourself for every breath you took. I figured one of us had to keep standing.”
The barn goes quiet. I look away, shame burning hot on my face.
“I wasn’t stronger than you, Chesney.” His voice is steady. “I just knew Mom couldn’t lose another son.”
Part of me always resented Truett a little because it seemed like his life continued, while mine came to a screeching halt.
“But then she did anyway,” I murmur, avoiding his gaze. “Because I left.”
Truett sighs deeply, and I can feel his eyes on me. “She understood why you left,” he says. “Out of everyone, his death hit you the hardest. I think she worried if she forced you to stay, she’d end up burying you next.”
I lift my gaze as my heart stutters. “Did she say that?”
“Not in so many words.” He shakes his head. “But I know I worried about that too.”
Something inside me cracks. I never, not even once, thought of it that way. I know I was just a kid dealing with the kind of trauma most kids never have to deal with, but not for the first time, I wish I would’ve been able to see the way my grief was hurting everyone around me.
My selfishness cost me my brother, but I never realized what it did to my mom.
“I was with Jasper.” The confession comes so quietly, I’m not sure he even hears it. Glancing up, I say, “The night of the accident. I was supposed to be watching Lyle, but I left him upstairs and snuck away to meet Jasper. Truett, while our little brother was dying, I was too busy having sex with someone I never should’ve been with in the first place.” The pressure building behind my eyes is almost unbearable. “If I would’ve just fucking stayed home that night, he’d still be here.”
Truett is quiet for a moment. His jaw is tight as he watches me with tears in his eyes. I can’t tell what he’s thinking, but I can certainly imagine. Sitting forward, he rests his elbows on his knees, and his eyes soften.
“Chesney, you can’t think like that. You didn’t kill Lyle.”
“Well, it sure as hell felt like it back then.”
I’m reminded of when Jasper said something similar. My chest aches thinking about him. After the night at the diner, things between us have been fine. I guess. Maybe even more than fine. We do our best to stay out of each other’s way most days on the ranch, but we’re…friendly. I know it was the right thing to do, putting a stop to things before they got messy, but I’d be lying if I said it didn’t make me sad. And that I didn’t wish things could be different. It wouldn’t be fair to him, knowing I don’t know what my future holds. I hurt him once. I can’t do it again.
“Everything makes a little more sense now,” Truett says. “You weren’t just grieving our brother. You were carrying the weight of his death on your back. Why did you never tell me?”
I huff a somber laugh, then swallow down the rest of my beer. “I was ashamed. I hated myself for what I did, and wanted to punish myself for what happened to him. I didn’t think I deserved your—or anyone’s—understanding or sympathy. In my eyes back, I killed our brother and deserved the pain.”
“I get that, but I hate that you carried all that by yourself. I hate that you pushed me away.”
“Yeah, well, I pushed a lot of people away back then,” I mutter under my breath.
“Including Jasper?”
I nod. “Especially Jasper.
“That’s why you were arguing with him outside in the dark a few days after Lyle died.”
My heart slams into my ribs as confusion furrows my brow. “How the hell do you know about that?”
“I saw the two of you.” Truett’s voice stays calm. “Out of the kitchen window.”
“I’m realizing that you see a little too much for my liking,” I murmur.
That makes him laugh. “Or maybe you’re just not as sneaky as you think you are.”