AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Marriage Meltdown

Page 44

by Maggie Linn Sharpe

Bailey’s gaze is on his brother’s retreating back. “I’m not sure, but I’ve never seen him go all gruff. He’s usually upbeat and friendly, but I guess he has been kind of cagey lately.”

“Cass looked like she’d seen a ghost. There’s definitely a story there,” I chirp. We all study her for another moment until she shoots a death glare our way. We shrug off the weirdness and go back to discussing what songs our group wants to perform.

Dan nudges me. “Do you want to do a duet?”

My eyebrows shoot up in surprise. He’s done duets with me in the past, but I usually had to twist his arm and promise sexual favors to get him to do it. He keeps surprising me.

“Yeah, what did you have in mind?”

“Oh, I’ll think of something,” he says with a bright smile.

I grin back at him, excited to see what he comes up with.

About an hour later, I’m on stage with a microphone in my hand, and I still have no idea what song Dan picked. I shoot him an anxious look as he joins me on the small stage.

“Are you seriously not gonna tell me?” I ask, low-key panicked. I didn’t get a chance to prepare.

“Don’t worry, baby. I picked a song you for sure know, and your part doesn’t start right away. We’ll be fine.” He winks and nods at Leena to start the music track.

I instantly recognize “The Next Ten Minutes” from The Last Five Years, and I relax. I could sing this musical in my sleep, and he’s right: the Cathy part doesn’t come in until the second verse.

As I listen to Dan sing the Jamie verse, I start to wonder what made him pick this song. The show is literally the story of how a relationship falls apart. The couple gets divorced in the end. I know it’s just a song at open mic night, but it feels like a bad omen.

We make it through the song, but my mind is still stuck in the spiral, thinking about what it all means. Are we going through this whole dating thing to end up divorced, anyway? I’ve finally gotten to the point where I have hope for our marriage. For so long, it felt like the only way forward was out, but now, I think we could make it work. What if I’m getting my hopes up for nothing?

At the same time, what if we decide to make it work, and all the changes Dan has made evaporate? How do I know if I can trust him to keep up his end of the bargain when it’s what got us into this mess in the first place? The questions keep cycling through my brain, making me irritated and sad.

Dan can sense my weird mood, and he keeps shooting me worried looks. So do Leena, Annie, and Cass, but I can’t shake it. Even singing “Golden” from K-Pop Demon Hunters with Leena and Annie can’t quite lift me out of my spiraling worries.

Eventually, Dan asks if I’m ready to head upstairs, and I nod. We say a quick goodnight to our friends, and we head behind the bar. We’re both quiet going up the stairs, and I know we have a conversation coming. I need answers to some of the questions flying through my brain.

The door closes behind us, and I can feel Dan’s eyes on me as I fill my water bottle at the fridge. I’m avoiding his gaze, trying to decide what I want to say first when he beats me to it.

“Jessie. Can you look at me?” he says in a tortured voice. I clench my jaw and lift my eyes to his. I can see the pain and worry in his gaze, and I’m flooded with guilt for acting so weird tonight. “What’s going on?”

“Why did you pick that song?” I ask quietly. He startles, like he wasn’t expecting it to be the first thing I said.

“Uh, I looked up romantic Broadway duets and remembered you liked the show,” he mumbles and shrugs. “The lyrics seemed nice.”

I stare at him for a long moment before throwing my head back and laughing hysterically, relief making me feel crazy. The confusion filling his face only makes me laugh harder before I collapse onto the couch, unable to stay upright. I got so in my head about his song choice meaning something, and he doesn’t even remember the story of The Last Five Years.

“Oh my God, I’m sorry,” I wheeze out between laughs. He comes over to sit next to me on the couch with a wary expression on his face.

“You want to fill me in?” he grumbles out. He stretches out his arm along the back of the tiny couch, and I take the opportunity to move into the space under his arm. I rest my head on his chest, and he drops his arm over my shoulder, planting a kiss on the top of my head.

“I’m sorry,” I say softly, blowing out a big breath. “I got really in my head about the song, and then kind of started spiraling about us.”

“I don’t understand what’s wrong with the song?”

“Dan, you didn’t look up the plot of the show at all, did you?”

“Uh, no. Just the song lyrics,” he says carefully.

I chuckle again. “Yeah, the two characters singing that song end up divorced in the end. The show is literally about how their relationship falls apart.”

He groans and runs a hand down his face. “Fuck. I just thought it was a nice song.” He laughs and studies me for a moment before getting serious again. “You said you were spiraling…”

I sigh and let my eyes close, gathering my nerve to respond to his unspoken question. “Things have been going well between us, but I was worried after this whole dating thing, we still might not make it work. Or we’ll try again, and everything will go back to how it was before. I’m afraid to get my hopes up.”