Page 8
“You want him dead.”
Her eyes flick up and she nods. “This is weird.”
“Weirder than drunkenly looking for a gun for hire last night?”
Noelle’s mouth twists and she shrugs.
“Hazel mentioned something about you not trusting the cops?”
Again, she nods. “I thought they would help me but they didn’t. They let him go free.” She shudders. “A jury found him not guilty.” She takes another bite. “Do I have to prove to you what I had to prove to them?”
“No. I just need you to tell me why you want him dead. I don’t care what the court says.”
She finishes her bacon strip and then reaches for another with trembling fingers. It’s not until she picks it up that I notice she’s trembling all over, like she’s seconds away from shaking apart all over her kitchen floor.
“Toby… he was just a man. Just a man I met once in a grocery store. I was in the way of something he wanted to look at, so I moved out the way and then paid him no attention. He was just a stranger. He seemed polite and that’s all it was, but then…”
She clears her throat and rapidly crunches down on the next piece of bacon, so I lean over and pour her a coffee, then fill my own cup.
“Two and a half years ago, three days after we met at the grocery store, I was walking home from a club with my best friend, Anne. We’d known each other since high school. She was smart and brilliant and funny, everything I aspired to be. She was becoming an architect, how amazing is that?” Noelle’s lips twitch, but the brief smile goes nowhere near her eyes.
I remain silent.
“I had no dreams that big. I was just happy to have a job and an apartment. Small dreams.” She reaches for another slice of bacon but only eats half before she sets it aside. “We were walking home from the club and he came out of nowhere. I remember…” She lifts her hand and mimics the motion as she speaks. “His fist came at my face so quickly that I didn’t have time to react. I fell and I saw him punch Anne. He was on top of her, punching her over and over and over. I screamed for help and he turned, like his entire body was twisting, and he punched me so hard, I fell back and hit my head. When I woke up… we weren’t on the street anymore.”
Noelle speaks flatly, as if she’s reciting something from memory. Given that my search online revealed a long legal battle, I don’t blame her.
“Where were you?” I ask, picking up my coffee. I keep my movements slow but constant so that she always knows I’m here.
“Some room somewhere. There was plastic over the walls and lights above me. I was on this really cold, hard table and I couldn’t move. He’d tied me down.”
“Tied you down how?”
Her eyes snap up. “Is this some kind of interrogation?” she asks sharply.
“No,” I reply calmly. “Details help me know if you’re telling the truth.”
“So you think I’m a liar?” She’s already getting heated and anger ignites like flames in her eyes while her cheeks flush. Her defense is clearly triggered from carrying a pain no one trusts.
“No. But if I’m going to kill someone, I need to make sure it’s the right person for the right reasons.”
Her jaw tightens and sharpens into an edge, then she grunts. “He tied down my wrists and ankles, and there was a belt across my shoulders and one across my thighs. He did the same to Anne.”
“Where was she?”
Noelle’s eyes dart down to the pancakes and she picks one up. “On the table next to me. She wasn’t close, not right beside. She was across the room.”
“And Toby?”
“Nowhere at first.” Her voice wobbles slightly. “I tried to get her to wake up. I tried but she wouldn’t. I don’t know what was wrong, but she wouldn’t wake up, and then he was there. He was there and he was cutting into her and she woke up screaming. I begged him to stop. I begged and I pleaded and I tried to tell her it would be okay, but he wouldn’t stop and she wouldn’t stop and it was…”
Try as she might, her voice doesn’t remain flat for long. Pain and exhaustion lace her words and the pancake she picked up turns to a sea of crumbs in her fist.
“He cut out her kidney and showed it to me. She was lying there, screaming and crying while he had her… her organ in his hand.” She shakes her head back and forth. “I threw up everywhere. It was… It was horrific.”
My stomach tightens slightly. “What did he do with it?”
She shrugs. “I don’t know. He told me he was selling it. I saw him put it in a cooler and I never saw it again. I thought he was going to do the same to me but he was… different with me.”