Page 53
“And you’re…” A shaky inhale. “You said you’re her daughter. Is she okay?”
“She passed over a year ago,” Reese says, and Bonnie inhales sharply.
“I’m so sorry,” she murmurs. She sounds lost in thought, but then she coughs and says, “I’m sorry… but what can I do for you?”
Her tone is a little aloof and Reese looks at me with a frown. “I know this is coming from left field, but… well, I’m searching for information about my mom, and my journey led me to Whynot, and that’s how I found your name.”
“Did she run off and leave you too?” Bonnie asks, and yeah… there’s anger there. But before Reese can say a word, Bonnie apologizes. “I’m so sorry. That sounds so mean, and I don’t want to be that way. Your mom… she just…”
Her words trail off, but Reese fills them in. “She left you, I know. Left Whynot without a word and disappeared.”
Bonnie makes a choked sound, and I can hear the tears. She sniffles, takes in a breath. “I have to say…” Another sniffle. “I honestly thought she’d died. I’d thought something bad happened to her, which is why I never heard from her again. I’m truly glad to know she didn’t… that she apparently became a mother.”
“I can imagine that this is a shock to hear from me. Maybe let me fill you in a bit.”
Reese takes ten minutes to talk about Vivian Bellamy Cartier, the woman she became. She tells Bonnie that she was a wonderful mother and wife, and that when she died, she carried with her the secret of her mysterious past and how that led Reese to Whynot.
“She kept that pageant sash?” Bonnie says with a dry laugh. “Of all the things.”
“It’s what led me to Whynot. I didn’t even know her name was Melissa Rhodes and I’ve been down here trying to figure out who she was before me, and every single road leads back to you. To her best friend, Bonnie Tutwiler.”
She falls apart on the other end of the line with a soft, wet, broken sound, a woman’s breath catching around a thirty-five-year-old wound.
Eventually, she settles herself. “I’m sorry. To be honest, I hadn’t thought about your mom in a long time, but I’m truly glad to know she had a beautiful life after… well, after she left Whynot. What can I help you with, Reese?”
“Well, I’ve learned a fair amount about her growing up here, about her parents and the pageant. There was, as you know better than anyone, a lot of drama after she was crowned Miss Whynot.”
Bonnie snorts. “Those silly mill rumors. It was ridiculous and I guess it’s easy to laugh about it now. But it wasn’t all that funny back then.”
“I heard how the whole town decided you did it out of jealousy over losing to Melissa. But I also learned there wasn’t any truth to that. I talked to Sheriff Tatum and while it’s never been solved, he knew without a doubt you didn’t do it.”
“You know, when I think back on that time, I don’t really think about that stupid fire or the rumors about it. I only equate that time to your mom leaving town and never hearing from her again.”
“Didn’t she tell you she was leaving?” Reese asks. And it’s a good question, because I just assumed her mom would have confided in Bonnie.
“No. But the last time we talked, I remember her trying to comfort me amid all those swirling rumors. She promised me that she was going to handle it. I never did quite understand how she was going to do it, but then… she was gone.”
“Oh,” Reese breathes out in a soft, horrified realization. “You didn’t know about the letter she sent to the sheriff, did you?”
“Letter?”
“My mom wrote a confession letter to Bo Tatum that she’d set the fire. Of course, the sheriff didn’t pay it any mind. Knew neither of you two had set it since you were at a sleepover that night and all accounted for.”
“Your mama confessed?” Bonnie asks, her voice sharp as a knife.
“Well, not sure it was really much of a confession. The sheriff didn’t believe it, but—”
“That’s why she left,” Bonnie exclaims, giving voice to my suspicion. “She thought the sheriff would believe it, and she was going to outrun the law.”
“That’s my theory as well,” Reese murmurs.
“Oh, that stupid girl,” Bonnie says quietly, but there’s no anger in it now. It’s all sadness. “I’d have been fine, you know. I was fine. The mill ran out of steam, which is what it always does.”
“I don’t think she could help it,” Reese says thickly. “From everything I’ve heard and what I know about her… I think that’s just who she was.”
“It is.” Bonnie’s crying again. “It is exactly who she was. She’d have set herself on fire before she let it touch somebody she loved.” A ragged breath. “I’m sorry, Reese. I’ve been so angry at her underneath, and now I’m ashamed of being angry, because how do you stay mad at a girl who was trying to…”
She can’t finish it.