Page 38
I didn’t think my humiliation could get worse, but it just got worse. Because now I’m thinking about that tongue piercing and how it moves when he talks, and how it might move and feel when he does other things with his tongue.
“Hmm?” What was the question?
Heat crawls up my neck.
His eyes flick to the dot of frosting on my nose. And his jaw flexes, like he’s restraining a reaction.
Then, he starts to crouch, reaching for the cake.
My brain finally registers something other than shirtless Connor with a tongue ring and becomes alert to the real emergency.
The cake.
“NO!”
It comes out muffled because my mouth is still full, but he must understand because he freezes mid-crouch and looks up at me, eyebrows lifting.
“I was going to—"
“Throw it away?” I finish, horrified. “Absolutely not.”
He glances from the frosting crime scene on the tile to my face like he’s trying to decide if I’m joking.
“It’s on the floor,” he says carefully. “There are germs.”
“Five second rule,” I claim like I’m enacting a peace treaty.
“The five second rule isn’t really a thing.” His eyes trail over the fallen cake. “Especially not in this situation.”
“Okay, Mr. Discovery Channel,” I snap, already dropping to my knees. “Not helpful.”
I bend down and use the edge of the plate as a scoop to lift the cake back onto the plate, then give it a little push with my hand. It’s not great. The slice is now a tragic heap of frosting and pineapple and crushed pecans, but it’s still Esther’s famous Hummingbird cake. Still mine.
I cradle the plate like it’s a lifeline.
“It was perfect,” I say, and my voice comes out smaller than I mean it to. “It was Esther’s Hummingbird cake.”
Connor pauses for the briefest second, eyes flicking up to mine like he caught the sincerity.
“You’re still going to eat that?”
“Absolutely.”
He gestures vaguely at me.
“You’re Rory’s sister.”
The words land soft.
They still hit hard.
Because it’s a reminder that in this world, I’m not always me. Oftentimes, I’m reduced to my proximity to Rory. Like I didn’t earn my own medals, my own lane, my own life. Like I’m not standing here with cake on my face and a whole future I’m trying to build that doesn’t have to be in Rory’s shadow.
And somehow it stings more coming from him—because Connor Fisk isn’t looking at me like I’m someone’s little sister. He’s looking at me like a problem. A temptation. Like even though he’s calling me Rory’s sister, he knows there’s more.
My smile snaps into place—bright, sharp, sugar-coated.
“My name is Whitney,” I say, sweet as frosting and twice as dangerous.