AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Against the Current

Page 69

by Erin Hawkins

That has my shoulders releasing a small amount of tension. But there’s still the fact that this is a small town. Someone might see me going inside with her, and word could get back to Rory.

Keep your head down. No complications. The advice from Leo that seems simple in theory, but with Whitney in my proximity, it’s far more challenging to regard.

Whitney turns to find me waiting in the doorway like I’m a vampire that has to be invited in.

“Come in.” She waves me toward the kitchen. “It’s not like Rory is going to jump out of the bushes. He left for Charleston this afternoon.”

“Right.”

Inside, the house is warm and lived-in—throws draped over the back of the couch, a bowl of keys by the door, and a colorful rug leading down the hallway.

I carry the bags into the kitchen and set them on the counter, then start lining the groceries up by category without thinking—cold, dry, snacks—because my hands need something to do.

Whitney stares at my progress, amused. “Winnie is a stickler for food organization. You two would get along.”

She motions to a cabinet, and I peer inside to find labels on the shelves indicating the places for cereal, oatmeal, and granola bars.

“This is impressive.”

“Don’t worry. It won’t last long. I have a tendency to bring disorder to systems.”

Captain Chaos. That’s what she’s called online.

She tears open the box of ice cream sandwiches.

“You know you could wait until that refreezes.”

She narrows her eyes at me. “Says the man who wanted me to throw away my Hummingbird cake.”

“It was on the floor. Of a highly trafficked area.”

“Are we really going to debate this again?” Her brows lift before she slides her tongue against the edge of the ice cream sandwich, the soft, melting ice cream easily giving way.

“The cake. The Nude dog. Now an ice cream sandwich,” I say, watching her take another bite like she’s daring the laws of physics to stop her. “I’m noticing a pattern.”

Whitney pauses mid-chew. “What pattern?”

“You and food all over your face,” I say.

She squints at me like I’m being dramatic, then takes another bite anyway—cookie nudging into the corner of her mouth and leaving a scatter of crumbs behind like evidence.

I should let her handle it, but I don’t.

Before I can talk myself out of it, my thumb goes to the corner of her mouth and sweeps the crumbs away in one clean motion.

Whitney stills.

So do I.

Because now I’m standing in Winnie’s kitchen touching Whitney’s lips like this is normal, like my self-control didn’t just slip on melted ice cream.

Her eyes flick to my hand, then back up to my face, mouth twitching.

“So, if I’m messy…” she says, voice sweet in a way that makes my pulse misbehave. She takes another slow bite, like she’s testing a theory. “…you’ll clean me up?”

Heat crawls up my neck, and I quickly drop my hand.

“That’s not—” I start, then stop, because my brain is busy imagining things it shouldn’t.