AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Against the Current

Page 71

by Erin Hawkins

“Sea of Thieves is my favorite,” she says, and the words hit like a ton of bricks.

Of course it is.

“I remember that one,” I manage, because my mouth is still pretending the rest of my body isn’t in panic mode.

Whitney’s eyes light up. “We should play.”

“I don’t think⁠—"

“Come on. You’ll pick it back up fast.” She rushes over to the couch, then pats the spot beside her like she’s casually inviting a friend and not pushing me toward a cliff. “It’ll be fun.”

This is where I should say no.

This is where I should remember Vivi’s voice—be boring—and Leo’s—no variables—and my own plan to stay the hell away from her.

But she’s looking at me with those big blue eyes that were clearly designed to dismantle my internal alarm system.

Instead, I hear myself say, “Uh...I forgot my login.”

Whitney waves it off immediately. “Use mine. Or use Winnie’s profile. She only has one because I forced her to try it once. She won’t mind if you suck.”

I sit down, stiff and on edge, like a man who wants to keep his secrets.

Whitney signs in, fingers flying, and there it is on the screen.

SailorGirl.

My chest goes tight—sharp, instant, unmistakable. I attempt to keep my face blank and my breathing steady and my hands loose, but I know for a fact I’m white-knuckling the edge of the couch.

“SailorGirl.” I can’t help saying it out loud. I hope she doesn’t hear the longing and reverence in my voice.

She glances at me. “Yeah, that’s my gamertag.”

My throat bobs.

“That fits,” I force out.

She smiles, proud, then tilts her head. “What’s yours?”

I could tell her now. Say my gamertag and blow everything up. Turn Whitney’s hopeful gaze into an accusing glare.

I know I’m being selfish. Letting her think I’m just a new teammate looking for a fresh start, when the reality is I started digging the hole I’m in the moment I left that coffee shop and ghosted her.

But maybe one game is harmless. A way to pass an otherwise lonely afternoon.

Just one game.

“Don’t recall.”

Whitney’s eyes narrow like she can sense my lie. “Sure you don’t.”

Then, she leans back, a wicked grin on her face. “Let me guess. Is it ‘BigFishEnergy?’”

“No.”

“‘CockedAndDocked?’”

I choke. “Absolutely not.”