AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Sin Cleaver

Page 184

by Heather C. Myers

Levi.

She meant Levi.

I kept my hands flat against my thighs. Kept my breathing where it needed to be. Let her watch my face and find nothing useful there, because there was nothing I was giving her, nothing she'd paid for, nothing she'd earned.

"Your mother found out," Edith continued. "Not because your father confessed. Men like him don't confess—they just become careless." Something moved across her expression. Not regret. Closer to contempt dressed up as sympathy. "She confronted him. Publicly. At that church. All that righteous noise." She tilted her head, the lamplight sharp across her cheekbone. "You remember the scene she made? Or were you too young?"

I was seven.

I didn't say it.

"The fire was an accident," Edith said, and the way she said it—smooth, settled, worn down to habit—told me she'd been saying it so long she may have even started to believe it.

She leaned forward slightly.

"What happened to your mother was the consequence of a woman who couldn't control herself in a room full of people who had a great deal to lose." Her voice didn't waver. "I didn't start that fire, Greyson. Your mother's spectacle did."

Olivia moved beside me. A small shift of weight, the kind people make when they want to speak and stop themselves.

I looked at Edith. Really looked at her—past the silk, past the composure, past thirty years of architecture she'd built over one night.

"And your mother?" Edith said. "She stayed." She let it breathe. Let it sit in the air between us the way a smell sits in a room. "Raised that child like it was her own."

The warmth in her voice when she said it was the worst part. Constructed warmth. The kind that existed only to make something sound like pity when it was actually a knife.

She was watching my face.

I gave her nothing.

But behind my eyes something was moving, pulling loose from wherever I'd packed it down over the past twenty-three years. The kitchen table. The particular sound of my mother's voice when she thought no one was listening. The way she used to smooth Levi's hair back from his forehead with her palm—same gesture, every time, the same automatic tenderness she gave me and my brother like it cost her nothing. Like it never had.

Edith tilted her head. "A saint," she said softly. "Or a fool. Depending on how you look at it." The corner of her mouth curved. Not a smile. An arrival. "Most women would have left." She settled back in her chair, unhurried, the way someone settles into a story they've already finished. "Your mother chose to stay in a house that humiliated her. Chose to love a child that was proof of everything her husband had done. Chose—" the pause was surgical, "—to make herself small enough to survive it."

The lamp burned between us. The wind moved through the room.

My hands were still flat against my thighs. I was aware of them the way you're aware of something you're holding very carefully. The memory of the kitchen table pushed harder. Levi at six years old eating cereal, legs swinging, my mother's hand on the back of his neck, her face turned toward the window. That particular expression she wore sometimes when she thought no one was watching. Not miserable. Something quieter and worse than miserable. Resigned. Like a person who had negotiated with grief so long they'd started to mistake it for peace.

I had spent twenty-eight years not thinking about that expression.

Edith was still talking.

"Weakness dressed up as virtue," she said. "Your mother called it love. The rest of us called it⁠—"

"You're wrong."

The voice came from my right. Quiet. Firm. No waver in it.

Edith stopped.

I turned.

Olivia stood with her arms loose at her sides, her ruined dress still damp at the shoulder, her chin level. She wasn't looking at me. She was looking at Edith, and her face had the particular quality it got when she'd stopped calculating and started feeling—open, unguarded, almost reckless.

"Staying isn't weakness." Her voice didn't rise. "Choosing to love something that costs you everything isn't weakness." Something moved through her expression, tight and certain. "You're describing a woman who refused to let her son grow up without a mother. Who refused to let a child grow up without one either." Her jaw tightened. "You're calling that humiliation because it's the only way you can live with what you did to her."

Edith looked at Olivia the way you look at something unexpected in a room you thought you'd already searched.

Olivia didn't flinch.