AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Until I Found You

Page 141

by Erika Kelly

But there was no use in writing the ending to her story before she lived it, so she tuned back into Denise, who was fielding questions. “I hear you, and it is a little outdated, but we just don’t know what else to do. We’ve got so many fundraisers going on all year long, we were trying to find something different.”

“What if we have a pie-throwing competition?” Decker asked.

Silence hovered in the room, and Willa had no idea where that idea would land. But someone said, “Oh, I like that.”

“How would that work?” Denise asked.

“There’s bound to be a world record for pie-throwing,” Decker said.

“Looking it up now,” Knox called as she tapped on the keypad of her phone. Fabric swished as people turned in their seats to wait for her. Her arm shot up in triumph. “Twenty-three hundred and ninety-four pies thrown in one continuous pie fight.”

“Oh, that’s a lot,” Phinny said.

“I mean, we’re literally getting hundreds a day for the festival,” Willa said. “And that’s on short notice. Imagine if we got the word out. We could use community kitchens⁠—”

A beautiful blonde woman stood up. “I’m the owner of Wally’s in Owl Hoot. We’ll help.”

“I run the senior center,” a man said. “Our members would love to help. It’ll be a great project for us.”

“I like it,” Denise said. “It’s kid-friendly, and it’s a boon for the entire town. We’ll promote it throughout the valley, get businesses to sponsor it. It’ll help the whole community.” She looked at Decker. “You’ll help coordinate that?”

“Hey, his season starts in five weeks,” someone shouted. “Leave him out of it.”

Laughter exploded—more out of excitement for the idea than the comment itself. The room was abuzz with organizing. Someone started calculating how many ovens they’d need, and others threw out suggestions for a venue.

And as the town began building around his idea, a longing took form, one so outside the scope of her dreams and hopes and ambitions that it made no sense.

At the same time, nothing had made more sense.

Imagine if I could stay in town.

If I were the general manager.

She glanced at Decker. Imagine if he wanted to stay, too. Not now, of course. Not even next year. But if he came back after he retired.

And we could keep building a life together.

Birdie flashed into her mind.

A family.

Oh. Her heart fluttered wildly.

Yes. Oh, yes.

Images dropped into her mind. The three of them making pies. Sitting on a bench in the town square, licking ice cream cones. Strolling the grounds of the county fair.

A life so different, so beautiful, she couldn’t imagine ever going back to New York.

Decker lay on his back, staring at the ceiling of Willa’s childhood bedroom, the faint beam from the streetlight slicing across the room the way it always did.

For once, his mind wasn’t racing ahead to schedules or swelling percentages or durability timelines. He was happy exactly where he was.

Willa had fallen asleep with one hand draped across his ribs, her fingers twitching now and then like she was having a lively conversation in her dreams. He studied her face in the angled light—the curve of her cheek, the small crease between her brows she got when she was thinking too hard. He’d never felt this kind of rightness before. Not after a playoff win. Not after a record-breaking game. Not even the first time he’d been handed the keys to the franchise.

This was different.

He’d formally hired the nanny that afternoon. She seemed good with Birdie. Competent. Between that and her impeccable credentials and glowing references, how could he go wrong? He’d set the start date. Sent her first paycheck to keep her locked in.