Page 63
“I don’t understand. You were playing both of us to see which one would work out?”
When he didn’t answer, she knew she had it right. “Well, whatever love story you and Kendall plan on telling your future children, it still comes down to a guy who slept with two sisters. Shame on you.”
“Call it what you want, but I don’t feel shame. I’m building a future with someone.” He paused, his voice gentling. “It’s different with her.”
In the end, she was just a woman who’d been rejected, and it hurt. No amount of bravado could take away the sting. She hated the question even as it pushed past her lips. “Different how?”
“I’m thinking long term, Willa. About the firm. About my career. About the kind of life I want.”
“I’m literally the definition of that life. That’s why we worked. We wanted the same things.”
“With you, it was temporary.” He hurried to add, “Which is what you wanted.”
“I didn’t get there fast enough? Is that what you’re saying?”
He sighed. “I don’t think it was there for us. We didn’t have a connection outside of work.”
Her throat tightened. “But you and Kendall do?”
“Sure, yeah. We’re already talking about kids, about getting a place in Tribeca. We just… fit.”
“Do you…” She swallowed, hating herself for asking. “Is it better with her? Does she make you happier?”
“Willa…” He exhaled. “You’re smart. You’re fun. You’re a great attorney.”
“Answer the question.”
“Yes, okay? She makes me happier. It just works.”
Her hand pressed to her chest, but nothing softened the tight, aching knot. She forced herself back to neutral ground. “I get that we didn’t work out. I’m okay with that. Neither of us developed feelings, but you should’ve ended things with me before you started dating my sister. Don’t you see that?”
“Sure, I do. But I’m looking at the next fifty years. It might be uncomfortable in the office for a while, but in the end, I get the life I want. Should I have talked to you? Yeah. But it wouldn’t have changed anything. I’d still be with Kendall.”
So, not some grand love story. That loosened the knot a little. But another thought slid in. “Did my mom… encourage you to date Kendall?”
That three-second beat of silence told her everything. “In a way. She thinks it’s a good match. For the firm. For all of us.”
The last fragile piece inside her chest cracked.
“So, the three of you talked it over,” Willa said. “And decided this made more sense.”
“It wasn’t some secret meeting. It just… evolved.” Then his voice shifted into office mode. “In any event, I hope we can put this behind us. We still have to work together, and we all have a common goal.”
She didn’t know there was a line until he crossed it. And she was done being the calm, polished professional. “You know what, Nate? Fuck you. I’m not here to make things easier for you. Were we a love match? No, but that’s not the point. You slept with two sisters. In the same office, run by the same mother. So if I make things uncomfortable for you, I guess that’s the consequence of bad judgment.”
She thumbed the End Call button before he could respond.
She was shaking. Filled with rage. She spun around, heading back to the kitchen to tell Decker what had just happened. He would not even believe these people. But on her way, her dad’s bedroom door opened…and a woman walked out.
Excuse me?
He’s got a girlfriend?
The dark-haired woman was younger than her dad—maybe late thirties. She smiled at Willa—not a hint of awkwardness.
Why didn’t Dad tell me he was seeing someone? Fired up by her call with Nate, she strode toward the woman with her hand out. “Hi.” Oof. That was way too aggressive. Still, she couldn’t control the hurt and anger roiling through her. “I’m Willa. Jack’s daughter.”
The petite woman smiled. “I’m so happy to meet you.” She shoved a pile of swatches under her arm to sandwich Willa’s hand between hers. “Your dad talks about you all the time. I’m Maria.”