Page 23
It felt strangely familiar, almost like I had stepped into another dream without realizing it. There was no smile, no greeting, just a long, unreadable look that made my pulse stumble for reasons I couldn’t explain. Heat spread across my cheeks first, then embarrassment followed close behind as I remembered the last time I thought of him and what I was doing at the time. This was not the time or place to think these thoughts, what was wrong with me? I cleared my throat quietly and tore my gaze away, pushing my attention to the flowers arranged beside the altar.
Moon flowers… My stomach tightened immediately.
Blue petals opened toward the stained-glass light, luminous even beneath the church candles. It was impossible. They were the same flowers he had shown me, the same delicate blossoms that had glowed beneath another sky in another world, their beauty hiding a poison he had spoken of almost affectionately.
“Blue moon flowers,” he had said. “Beautiful, but toxic. My favorite.”
My heart began pounding so violently I barely heard the opening prayer. What were the chances? I stared at them, searching desperately for some tiny difference that would prove my imagination had carried the memory into this room. There wasn’t one, every bloom looked exactly as I remembered.
My thoughts spiraled beyond reason. Did Father Hael know him? Had he seen the castle? Were those dreams truly dreams at all? Or had I truly wandered into something real without understanding it?
The questions came so quickly they collided with one another until I couldn’t tell one fear from the next. I stole another glance toward the priest just as he turned another page in the missal. His expression remained composed, reverent even, yet something about him unsettled me. There was something about him that screamed he’d followed me into my dreams, like he was a side to a coin I couldn’t find. They couldn’t have looked more different, really, one carried the ocean in his eyes, the other belonged to moonlight, and yet... standing only a few feet apart in my mind, they seemed connected by an invisible thread I couldn’t explain.
The remainder of the Mass passed like a blur of voices and prayer, while my own thoughts refused to obey. Every time I closed my eyes, I saw the castle balcony beneath a sky full of glittering stars, and every time I opened them, Father Hael stood before the altar, speaking of grace and forgiveness with a voice steady enough to calm storms. Somewhere between memory and reality, my heart became a battlefield I no longer understood. I wasn’t simply mourning the man from my dreams anymore, I was searching for him in every shadow, every old doorway, every forgotten story... and now, somehow, even in a church.
By the time everyone had left the church, a peaceful hush surrounded us. Candles continued to burn beside the altar, while Ophelia and I remained seated, waiting while Father Hael finished speaking with the last few parishioners. An elderly woman clasped his hands, thanking him for visiting her husband earlier that week, and he listened with the same quiet patience he had shown throughout the service. When a little girl rushed up to hug him before leaving, he laughed softly and knelt to her height, listening to an animated story about a stray kitten she’d found.
“I told you he was kind,” Ophelia whispered, following my gaze.
I nodded, unable to look away just yet. “I noticed.”
She smiled knowingly before nudging my shoulder with hers. “I meant genuinely kind. Not everyone who wears a collar carries compassion with them.”
I looked back toward the altar just as Father Hael straightened, saying goodbye to the family before making his way toward us. For a brief moment our eyes met again, and that strange, unsettling familiarity returned.
“Father,” Ophelia greeted warmly as he stopped beside us. “I’d like you to meet Mallory.”
His smile widened into something almost amused before he glanced between us. “I believe we’ve already met.”
“What? You didn’t mention that,” she questioned as she turned to me.
“Sorry…” I giggled, the sound somewhat strained as my cheeks grew hotter. “Hi Father Heal. It’s really nice to meet you again.” I extended a hand to shake, not knowing what else to do with myself.
“Likewise, likewise.” He chuckled, a smile reaching his eyes before his cold hand met mine.
“I almost thought you didn’t remember me, but seeing that you spent half the Mass staring at me, my worries vanished.” Heat rushed into my cheeks, neck, and ears so quickly I thought I might actually combust.
“I was looking at the flowers,” I protested. “The flowers that happened to be beside you.”
His chuckle echoed lightly through the quiet church and something warm settled in my chest. “I’ll accept that version of events.”
Even Ophelia laughed, leaving me to hide my embarrassment behind an awkward smile.
“It’s good to meet you properly, Mallory.” I returned the greeting before an easy silence settled between us. Father Hael glanced toward the church doors and released an exaggerated sigh. “I’ve been trapped inside this building since dawn.”
Ophelia folded her arms. “Trapped?”
“I may have taken vows,” he replied, “but nowhere in them did I promise to spend every waking hour inside a church.”
I laughed despite myself, the second genuine laugh since we started talking.
“Would you join me for lunch? There’s a little place across the square. Their coffee is questionable, their fries are excellent, and I desperately need proof that the outside world still exists,” he asked, the exhaustion in his eyes finally showing.
Ophelia smiled immediately. “Go. I’ll leave you both to it.”
Before I could object, she’d squeezed my hand, wished us a lovely afternoon, and disappeared down the church steps with a smile that suggested she’d planned this all along.
I couldn’t even blame her. What was happening to me needed serious divine intervention, at least that’s what I’m assuming she’s thinking.