AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Bad Elf Steals a Man

Page 117

by Alina Jacobs

Did he like what he saw?

Obviously not, if he just walked right out of there.

Not to mention I have undeniable proof that he didn’t like what he saw at all, considering he stopped me before I, you know, put the whole plate of Christmas cookies on display.

“Gah!” I tangle my hands in my hair.

Why does this always happen to me? This is worse than the time the seam of my pants split right open in art class and everyone laughed at me.

“Okay, almost worse. Let’s not catastrophize, Kittie.”

I don’t know whether I’m more humiliated that he saw my sad little peep show or that he didn’t find it arousing at all.

And worse, I was up all night and uncomfortably horny.

It didn’t help that I kept trying to get myself off and it didn’t work.

I don’t want a repeat of that, so I force myself out into the kitchen and pray that Lawrence hasn’t slipped back in.

“Biscuit!” I yell as I trip over the dog who is standing in front of the oven, where I have cranberry chocolate-chip sourdough proofing. I clutch the ornaments as I bang my hip into the stove.

Biscuit yelps and runs away.

“It’s your own fault,” I yell at her, my hip stinging.

“You’re clumsier than usual.” Georgie comes in and sets down the box of stained-glass paint she’s carrying.

“I didn’t sleep well.”

“Did you stay up all night talking to Mr. Fantastic? You told me he wanted to get frisky.”

“Lawrence cockblocked me.” I fill her in, red-faced.

“This is a good thing.” Georgie’s excited.

“No. I lost Mr. Fantastic.”

“No, it means Lawrence is into you.”

“I think he just liked humiliating me.”

“We can work with a humiliation kink.”

“I don’t want to relive my middle school days in a sexual fantasy.”

“I don’t think he wants to pee on you, just like, fuck you in a public place.”

“I already have, you know, performance anxiety issues,” my voice drops to a whisper. “I can’t take that kind of pressure. He says he knows what a woman sounds like when she comes.”

“I repeat. Even better,” Georgie says. “Now you can experience the wonders of sex—not just some guy with a small dick humping you like he’s about to have a heart attack. You should have just spread 'em wide and told him that he owes you for ruining your sex show.”

“I can’t do that,” I squawk. “What if he sees my, you know, condition and thinks it’s weird?”

“Guys like pussy. Don’t overthink it. You could be preggo and on your way to being the new owner of the Winterberry Inn by now. I thought you were stepping up your manhunting game.”

“God, why am I so useless? I feel like a stupid, awkward teenager, and I’m thirty. I should know how to do this.” I take a breath. “It’s because I’m going after unattainable men.”

We peek around the corner into the Conservatory Café and watch Lawrence. He’s helping with the last of the lunch rush.