AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Earl’s Christmas Redemption

Page 28

by Christina Diane

My wish for you is that you are happy. And loved. And as long as there is breath in my body, that latter part will always be true, even if I can’t be the one to make you happy.

Yours always, John

Maddie struggled to breathe through her tears. She wanted to run from the room and find him, to tell him she understood at last. Instead, she forced herself to turn the page, knowing she needed to finish what he’d asked her to read.

After composing herself, she read through his entries from the house party—his thoughts after their snowball fight, his jealousy of Louis, his desperate hope when they’d nearly kissed in the conservatory. Finally, she reached the last entry, dated from that morning:

To My Maddie,

I should feel remorse for what transpired between us in the library, but I cannot bring myself to regret a single moment. Your skin beneath my hands, the taste of your kiss, the way you called my name—these memories will sustain me if you choose to send me away.

I thought I had come to terms with losing you. I believed these moments near you would be enough to sustain me and I might finally let you go. But I was wrong. So catastrophically, gloriously wrong.

I still love you. I have never stopped loving you. Not for a single moment of a single day in these five long years. And now I find myself incapable of walking away from you again, unless you ask it of me. Even though I know I have no right to ask for your forgiveness, let alone your heart. And does that make me selfish that I don’t want to walk away?

If I could go back and undo the pain I caused you, I would sacrifice everything I possess. But since I cannot rewrite our past, I can only offer you what remains of me—a man forever changed by loss and regret, but also by growth and hope. A man who has learned through bitter experience the incalculable value of loving truly, and being truly loved in return. And a man who works every day to understand himself and how to be better for you.

I still love you, Maddie. In this life and whatever comes after. Whatever happiness awaits you, I pray it includes me, though I’ve done nothing to deserve such mercy.

And if you find that you still love this broken, unworthy soul, I’m waiting for you in the library tonight. And I’ll wait for you every night until you give me a reason not to.

Forever yours, John

Maddie’s hands trembled as she closed the journal. Tears flowed freely down her cheeks, and she made no effort to stop them. The raw honesty of his words, the depth of feeling contained in those pages, broke through every wall she might have built between them.

She rose from the chair, clutching the journal to her chest. All this time, she’d believed he’d left because he hadn’t loved her enough. But the truth was far more complex and heartbreaking—he’d left because he loved her too much to burden her with his struggles. Because in his darkest moments, he hadn’t believed himself worthy of her love.

She wiped away her tears with determination. Pain and hurt had kept them apart for too long. And she was done living a life without the man she loved.

Maddie knew what she had to do. She placed the journal carefully on the bedside table and smoothed her gown. The clock on the mantel showed it was almost midnight. The house would be quiet now, with most guests retired to their chambers after the evening’s festivities.

Maddie took a deep breath and opened her chamber door. Her decision was made. She would find John and tell him that despite everything, her heart had remained stubbornly, irrevocably his.

Chapter 11

John

The grandfather clock in the library's corner chimed midnight, each toll marking unsettling John’s nerves even more. He paced the length of the room like a caged animal, the fire in the hearth doing nothing to warm the chill of uncertainty that gripped him. It had been three hours since he’d handed Maddie his journal—three hours of torturous waiting, each minute stretching into eternity.

Outside, snow fell in thick, silent flakes, blanketing the estate grounds in pristine white. The Christmas Eve sky was a canvas of midnight blue and silver stars, and John imagined the couple from his story, which didn’t ease his fear that Maddie might not appear. He ran his hand through his hair for the hundredth time, disheveling the dark waves, and stopped before the fireplace, bracing one arm against the mantel as embers sparked and danced.

Would she come to him? Not that he would blame her if she didn’t.

His thoughts were a vicious cycle of hope and dread, memories of their passionate encounter in that very room. Maybe she’d read his journal, and it had only confirmed that she was better off without him and his troubles.

Doubt gnawed at him—he should never have given her the journal. He should have found the courage to say the words aloud instead of hiding behind ink and paper. And now it might be too late.

The door to the library opened with a soft click that pierced the silence like a gunshot.

John spun around, holding his breath. Maddie stood in the doorway, still dressed in the sapphire blue gown she’d worn to dinner. Moonlight from the window behind him cast her in silver light, giving her an almost ethereal quality. Her lips were slightly parted, her chest rising and falling with quickened breath. She’d come to him. Despite everything, she’d come.

For a moment, neither of them moved. The air between them seemed charged with intensity, with all the words they’d never said and the years they’d lost. Then she stepped into the room and closed the door behind her.

His throat constricted with emotion. “Maddie,” he said, her name rough in his mouth, tasting of longing and fear. “I wasn’t sure you’d—”

She crossed the room with swift, determined steps, her eyes still not leaving his. Before he could finish his sentence, she was there, wrapping her arms around him with a force that nearly knocked him backward.

“I still love you,” she said against his chest, her voice muffled but clear. “God help me, I never stopped.”