Page 14
“It’s okay. We’ll figure this out.” Everything in her seems to ease with those small words, and I can’t help but feel satisfied by that, by the fact that my words can so easily make her feel better.
“You can be mad at me,” she whispers, eyes wide. I shake my head.
“No, no. It’s fine, really. Hell, I’m the one who told you to get revenge.”
Her face screws up, and she shakes her head, making me drop my hand from her chin. I keep holding her hand, though, unable to force myself to let go.
“I don’t think you meant by pretending to be engaged to you.”
I lift a shoulder. “That’s the least of what I had in mind. I was thinking, like, put spiders in her wedding dress.”
She laughs, the sound loud and thrilling in my boring, empty apartment, and I think I’d like to hear it in my place more.
Often.
Always.
When it settles, she shakes her head, a nervous look crossing her face. Her eyes drift off as she pushes food around with her fork before finally looking at me, regret written clearly across her face.
“I really am so sorry, Connor. I shouldn’t have dragged you into this. Now you’re going to get a million calls from Shelby and Derek asking questions. What a shitty birthday for you.”
I laugh then, not at her or her concern, but because she’s so terribly wrong.
This isn’t the shittiest birthday.
In fact, it’s one of the best birthdays I’ve had in a while, between last night with her at my party, waking up with her in my bed, and spending the day with my family. Coming back to her waiting for me might have been the cherry on top.
I made a huge mistake in going after Shelby instead of Meadow all those years ago, something I’ve known for some time now. I ignored fate once before, but I’m determined not to make that mistake again.
“Anyway, I’m going to tell Shelby that I made it up soon, that it was a joke or something, but I wanted to let you know before things got back to you and you were left confused,” she says, cutting into my thoughts.
“Why would you tell her you made it all up?”
She tilts her head in an adorably confused way, as if she can’t figure out whether it’s her or me who’s lost their mind.
“Because I did?”
I lift a shoulder. “So? It’s not a bad idea.”
“It’s not?”
I shake my head, the thought moving through my mind over and over as I settle on it and come to a conclusion.
“I mean, we both have to go to this wedding and all of the events leading up to it, right? And it’s going to be awkward and miserable, and everyone is going to look at us all pitying and shit.”
She scrunches her nose, knowing it’s true.
Meadow is too sweet and too kind for her own good, too understanding and forgiving, and I wonder if maybe she needs someone in her life to tell her that this is all bullshit and she’s allowed to be mad about it.
“But if we have the buffer of being together, it wouldn’t be too bad. We should just pretend we’re engaged. We can say we’ve been keeping it under wraps. Now that Derek and Shelby are happy together, we don’t feel the need to hide our own happily ever after.”
She tilts her head, looking even more lost.
“If this is a proposal, it’s a really weird one, Connor,” she laughs.
My heart races as I grab the ring that, despite being a bit tough to remove, did fit Meadow perfectly, then move to one knee.
“Will you, Meadow Hanover, be my fake fiancée?”