AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Season to Get Even

Page 99

by Morgan Elizabeth

“Yeah, but they’re her favorite, so we all pretend they’re special. Been doing it since she was six.”

Meadow smiles softly at me, and I twine my fingers with hers before leading her to the couch, where Shae is already handing out stockings. They’re all handmade and crocheted, mine, the girls’, and dad’s all perfectly done, but Shae’s is a bit wonky, since my dad made it for her. He’s offered to replace it every year, but Shae threatened to leave him if he does, saying sentimental memories matter more than aesthetics.

“What’s this?” Meadow asks, eyes wide as she’s handed one with her name on it.

“Yours,” Shae says as if it’s obvious. “Connor picked out all of the things, though I added a few because he is, at the end of the day, a boy. Boys don’t realize stockings are for fun tchotchkes and not just essentials.”

Shae hands it over, then goes to get mine.

“What is this?” she repeats, her eyes beginning to water.

“Shae makes them for everyone in the family,” I explain.

“But I’m not—” she starts.

“You are,” I say simply, the two words saying a lot more than just two words. She bites her lip and looks around nervously, but no one is watching her, whether intentionally or not, I’m not sure.

“This had to have taken a while. When did she⁠—”

“As soon as we started this, I knew I wasn’t going to let you go.”

She swallows, her eyes growing watery. I take the stocking from her hands, set it aside, and pull her into me, knowing she wouldn’t want everyone to see her emotional.

“I can’t believe you’re real,” she murmurs into my neck. I smile at Shae, who sets my stocking beside me with a tight, watery one of her own, knowing, in her own way, how much this means to Meadow.

“And sometimes, I can’t believe you’re really mine,” I whisper for her ears only. She pulls back, and I wipe at her cheeks before kissing her softly. “Now open your stocking so Shae and the girls can make fun of my shitty present picking.”

She rolls her eyes but picks up the stocking, then looks around the room as if checking whether she’s caused a scene. Her shoulders relax when she notes everyone is busy with their own gifts. When she begins opening the first gift, I look at my dad, who is watching me now, a proud look on his face.

“Good job,” he mouths.

I smile, then start on my own stocking.

“She’s perfect for you,” Shae says a bit later as I go into the kitchen to grab a drink. She’s wiping down the counter, about to start making another huge meal while everyone is preoccupied. Dad and the girls have started their annual gingerbread decorating competition, and Meadow eagerly joined in, the girls determined to see her decoration skills in real time. They’re all giggling in the dining room now, the three women all ganging up on my dad’s inferior skills, not that he minds.

I smile at them, leaning on the counter.

“Yeah,” I say. “She is. She was worried that she would get in the way of a family day.” I remember the mild argument we got into two days ago, when I asked her to come to my dad’s for Christmas. She insisted she’d be fine staying home or going to Tori’s, but I wanted her with me, especially since I knew she wasn’t in a place to go to her dad’s for the holiday. We weren’t sure if Derek and Shelby would be there but agreed avoiding it would be the best choice, just in case.

It took a bit of convincing and a hint of guilt-tripping, a necessary evil, to get her to agree, but when she told me she had already bought my sister’s gifts, I knew it would be fine.

“Well, I hope she’s prepared to come here regularly. I think the girls are in love with her.”

Ruby calls her name and asks for advice on what to use for shingles, and I nod.

“Yeah, I can see that.”

A hand touches mine, and I look over at the woman who changed my dad’s life all because of some stupid dating app. A woman I met because, for a moment, the loneliness that quietly plagued me for years, up until a few weeks ago, had floated to the surface, making me want more. Like everything, I think that was meant to be. I was supposed to meet Shae so she could meet my dad, and I was meant to stay single until I could have Meadow.

The world works in beautiful, mysterious ways.

“I’m happy for you, Connor,” Shae murmurs, smiling at me.

“Who would have thought this is where we’d end up?” I say, and her eyes begin to water.

“You’re such an ass,” she says, her voice croaky as she pushes my shoulder. “I’m trying to be nice, and you’re trying to make me cry.”

I laugh, then pull her into my arms.