AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

To Have and To Fold

Page 63

by Emma St. Clair

The warm, solid reassurance of his touch has what’s probably a measurable impact on my body. If I were wearing some kind of monitor at a hospital, I’m sure it would register some deep, physiological change.

It’s enough to make me regret this whole conversation. My panic. The stupid reading glasses thing.

I feel foolish. One date—and I’m having a serious talk using ridiculous analogies.

“You’re afraid that this might not turn out to be what you hope?” he asks, and I nod.

“And maybe also … I’m scared that it will.”

Until I voiced this, I’m not sure I even knew it as true. But the moment they’re said, I realize this is really the root of my fear. Not that things won’t work and I’ll be disappointed, but that they will work out.

I am intimately familiar with disappointment and distress.

I’m not sure I remember or have the capacity to process this kind of happiness.

And that’s where this fear stems from. Clarity cuts through—but does not dull or assuage—my anxious feelings.

Gently, Tank’s thumb strokes the back of my hand, tracing a path back and forth. Slow. Steady. Comforting.

Even so, that light, safe touch wakes a yearning.

“About a year after Michelle died, James had this amazing football moment. He got chosen to play on the JV team, not the freshman team, which was a big deal already. He played cornerback—do you know what that is?”

I’m not sure why, but the fact that Tank is talking about something that seems so random and unrelated to my fears calms me. Or maybe that’s his touch. Probably both.

Either way, I feel slightly less panicked, and I’m definitely invested in the story, trying to picture a freshman year version of James Graham—tall but maybe not as tall as he is now, a little gangly, and definitely scowling.

“Cornerback—that’s not, like, some alternate version of a quarterback?”

Tank grins at this. “No. It’s a defensive position covering wide receivers.”

“I do know what receivers are,” I say.

“Good. So, he’s out there and the quarterback fakes a handoff, then throws to the receiver James is on. But James was able to read the play and intercepted the ball. He’s not the fastest of my sons—that was Pat—but he was big, even then. He sort of bowled his way through everyone and muscled his way to the end zone for a touchdown.”

Tank smiles, staring past me as though the memory is playing on the wall.

“I was in the stands with Collin and Pat and I had Harper on my shoulders—we were standing and cheering even before he crossed into the end zone. And as soon as he did, James looked up at the stands. They were packed, but we always sat in the same place for every game. He found us and his smile was so big—” Tank stops, seems to collect himself, and continues. “And I saw the moment he realized his mother wasn’t there and had to remember once again that she was gone.”

Forget feeling better. This story has ripped my heart out completely. I want to give Tank a hug and then march right down to the brewery, find James and give him one too.

Which makes my panic start to surge again because I am already way, way too invested not just in Tank but his family.

“He got swallowed up from view by his teammates and all the celebrating. That touchdown won them the game. I was so proud. But that night, I cried harder than I ever had over Michelle. Because it felt so incredibly wrong to have this big, important moment without her there. Happiness, joy, excitement—it didn’t feel fair or right or like something I was allowed to have. Not with her gone.”

Though I don’t have a specific memory like he does, I absolutely relate to this feeling. How happiness or simple enjoyment felt after David died. What it was like to sing happy birthday to Chelsea without him there, the strange guilt I felt once when I took the kids to Disney and rode a roller coaster, seeing my wild hair and wide smile in the photo afterward.

There was a wrongness, an inherent unfairness about it.

Even good weather felt like an affront in the early days. As in, how can we have this gorgeous day when I just had to make a choice on which casket to bury my husband in?

“I don’t like it when people say they know how you feel. How can anyone really know that? Half the time, I’m not sure I know how I feel, so how could they know? But I do relate to what you’re saying. Even all these years later, the idea of something good, specifically a potential relationship—the very thing we both lost already—comes with complicated feelings.”

“You don’t seem to feel complicated about it,” I say.

“Honestly, right now, I don’t feel complicated. But I bet I will. At some point or maybe at a lot of different points. I don’t know. I suspect, though, that falling in love after losing it—no matter how many years have passed or what those relationships were like—will come with surprises. Complications. Weirdness. Maybe even guilt. I think,” Tank says, “that’s just part of the deal.”

Every word resonates. Tank is so much more articulate than I am. Maybe wiser too. I’m over here giving reading glasses analogies while he is aptly describing all the things I couldn’t put words to.