AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

To Have and To Fold

Page 98

by Emma St. Clair

“My dad wasn’t very nice,” John says, finally, his eyes bright and his voice sharp.

I don’t react, though this is not where I expected the conversation to go.

“I mean, it’s not like he was a bad man. He wasn’t mean. He didn’t hurt Mom or us. He was good. He loved us. But he wasn’t … friendly or playful or soft. I don’t think he meant to, but he treated us—especially Mom—like we were a task on a checklist. He was very good at completing tasks. Which makes him a better father and husband, I guess, than many.”

Rose and I have talked about our late spouses, and I didn’t pick up on anything like what John is saying now. Their descriptions sound like two different men.

From what I remember her telling me, John was in high school when his dad died. So, it’s not a case of childhood memories skewing his perception. But I could see how John’s words might complete the picture, adding shadows and depth where Rose drew broad strokes. She did describe David as serious.

What serious means to a wife and to a son might look markedly different.

I’m still not sure where this is going, so I simply continue to wait and listen.

“I’ve become him,” John says finally.

His face crumples a little bit before he smooths his features out. I can see the strain and the effort it takes. If I didn’t think he’d pull away, I would reach out and give him a hug. But I can tell that would be the wrong move, so I grit my teeth and stand my ground.

“Or, I have been becoming him,” he continues. “I realized it lately, but I don’t know if I can stop. I think I thought he’s who I needed to be after he died. Someone had to.”

I ache for John, remembering now with sharp clarity all the ways my children dealt with Michelle’s death. Especially James, who stepped up when I fell apart, taking on tasks that never should have been his to take. I still feel guilty about letting him shoulder the weight for as long as I did.

It sounds like John, who’s also the oldest, took a page out of the same book as James.

“I don’t think the way you’re characterizing him sounds all bad,” I say, picking my words carefully. “Not if he loved you and took care of you in his own way. But if you see parts of him in yourself, and that’s not who you want to be, recognizing it is a good start.” I pause. “And I think you can honor his memory but still see his flaws. You can want to be a different man. Your own man. That’s okay too.”

I think I’ve overstepped or maybe ventured off in the wrong direction by the way John’s shoulders draw up stiffly. But then, he slumps a little, dipping his chin to his chest, scuffing a toe of his dress shoe along the sidewalk.

“I like your family,” he says.

I’m too shocked by the subject change to respond, but he keeps going anyway.

“They’re noisy and a little overbearing and don’t seem to have the normal kind of personal boundaries.”

Accurate. Though I’m not sure if he’s insulting me or trying to compliment me … or both.

I chuckle. “Thanks, I think.”

When John glances up, his face has changed. Gone is the hard, pinched expression he’s been wearing all night. He smiles, just a little one, and I can see Rose in it. “Sorry—I meant that as a good thing, but I can see how it sounds. What I’m trying to say is that there’s an openness to them. To you. It’s refreshing, and it’s good for my mom. You’re good for her. I can tell.”

“I’d like to hope so. I know she’s good for me.”

“Chelsea seems to fit right in with your family up there—even though she probably shouldn’t, considering the fact that she once dated your daughter’s husband and was responsible for him being sprayed by a skunk.” John shakes his head.

“Totally weird how that happened, right?”

“It is. On brand for my sister, though. I’m both surprised and also like, of course. If it were me? I don’t think I’d be cool with it. But Chelsea is totally the kind of person who can just … let go of things in that way. She can open up and let people in even if maybe she shouldn’t. I’m not like that.”

“But you want to be?” I ask.

“I don’t know what I want. Or if it’s possible for me to fundamentally change who I am.”

“Maybe you’re not seeing who you are clearly. If you aren’t happy in your skin, maybe it’s just that—a skin. One you can shed. Please don’t take offense to me comparing you to a snake.”

John laughs softly, then runs a hand over his jaw. “It works. And I like the idea of leaving this behind. I’m just so tired of trying so hard.”

“Now that is something I can relate to,” I tell him.

For a moment, neither of us speak. And though we don’t smile or make any move to embrace each other, it feels as though an understanding passes between us. I’m deeply relieved.