AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Earl’s Christmas Letter

Page 20

by Bronwen Evans

He had not expected to. He sat in his study until the fire burned down to embers and the candles guttered in their sockets, turning one word over and over in his mind like a coin he could not decide whether to spend.

Inevitable.

It had been the truest thing he could find to say on the ice, and it had been entirely the wrong one. He had seen it land. He had watched her flinch from it as though he had struck her, then lift her chin and tell him that nothing about her was inevitable. And he had stood there with snow in his hair and let her believe he meant it as Richard would have meant it. As a thing owed. As a thing already bought and paid for.

What he had meant was that he was lost. That he had been lost for five years and had only just found the courage to admit it. That loving her was not a choice he had made but a thing that had happened to him, slowly and then all at once, the way the frost had crept across the Serpentine until one morning a man could walk upon water.

He had not said any of that. He had said one arrogant word and offered her his arm.

Near dawn he unlocked the desk drawer and took out the letter.

He did not need to reread it. He reread it anyway, by the grey light creeping round the edges of the curtains, and for the first time since it had come into his hands he did not read it as a man reads a puzzle or a threat. He read it as she must have seen it the morning she discovered it gone. A secret that was not hers. A promise she had made to someone she loved. A thing she would rather be thought wanton than betray.

And he had kept it from her. For more than a fortnight he had kept it locked in a drawer like a hostage and called it a bargain.

I should like to be allowed to choose something for myself. Just once. Without anyone deciding it for me first.

James set the letter down on the blotter and looked at it for a long time.

He had told himself he held it for her protection. That he would keep it safe from prying servants and careless hands. That his terms were generous, for what was a few weeks’ courtship against the safe return of her secret? But he was honest enough, in the cold hour before dawn, to see what he had done. He had taken the one thing she valued above her own reputation and made it the price of his company. He had decided for her. Exactly as Richard had decided for her, with his parade of eligible gentlemen and his talk of alliances. Exactly as every man in her life had always done.

She would never choose him while he held it. How could she? Every smile she gave him would be a smile he had bargained for, and he would spend forty years across the breakfast table wondering which of them had been real.

He knew a great deal about wondering which smiles had been real. He had watched his father do it for twenty years.

James folded the letter carefully along its creases and slid it into the inner pocket of his coat, where he could feel the faint stiff edge of it against his heart.

He would give it back to her today. Without conditions. Without asking who had written it or to whom. He would put it in her hands, and then he would tell her the thing he had not been brave enough to say on the ice, and after that the choice would be hers. Entirely hers.

If she chose Bamberly⁠—

His jaw tightened. He made himself finish the thought.

If she chose Bamberly, then at least he would know she had chosen freely. And he would not become what his father had been: a man who spent his life loving a woman who only tolerated him for the sake of a bargain.

He rang for his valet and called for shaving water. Then he remembered, with a grimace, that he was promised to Richard at Jackson’s at ten.

He very nearly sent a note crying off. But Richard would only come hunting him to Grosvenor Square to discover why and talk of double weddings the whole way there. Better to go, take his punishment in the ring, and be at the Flint house by two.

He had, he thought grimly, a few things he would like to say to Richard in any case.

Gentleman Jackson’s rooms at No. 13 Bond Street were all but empty at that hour of a December morning. The Corinthians who crowded them in the afternoons were still abed nursing the effects of the night before. Only a pair of young bucks sparring clumsily in the far corner and a bored attendant sweeping fresh sawdust over the boards disturbed the quiet. The great man himself was not in evidence. The fire had barely taken the chill off the long room, and the windows were furred with frost.

Richard was already stripped to his shirtsleeves, swinging his arms and stamping his feet against the cold, his fair hair standing on end.

“There you are. I’d begun to think you’d turned coward.” He grinned. “Or that my sister had frightened you off. She has a tongue on her when she’s in a temper, doesn’t she? Mama gave me a thundering scold last night. Said I’d behaved like a horse coper.” He looked faintly aggrieved. “I only said what everyone is thinking.”

“That,” James said, shrugging out of his greatcoat, “is generally the trouble with what you say.”

He hung the greatcoat on its peg and his coat beside it. He felt the slight weight of the letter swing against the wood and turned away from it to unbutton his waistcoat.

“Is that a hint I’ve done something wrong? Because Mama has already told me, and Beth isn’t speaking to me, and even Louisa looked at me oddly in the carriage home.” Richard rolled his shoulders. “I don’t see what I said that was so terrible.”

James put up his hands and met him in the center of the floor. “You might have let her answer for herself.”

“She’d only have refused you. She refuses everyone.” Richard feinted left and jabbed right. James slipped it easily. “Somebody has to push her, or she’ll be sitting in Mama’s drawing room embroidering seat covers when she’s forty.”

“Perhaps she would like to be pushed by the man who wants to marry her. Rather than by her brother.”