AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Earl’s Christmas Letter

Page 5

by Bronwen Evans

Beth stared at him. For a moment the room seemed to tilt. “You cannot be serious.”

“I am entirely serious.”

“Why? Richard is your friend and would gut you if this is just one of your seductions.”

“I am offended. I do not seduce innocents. Except those I intend to marry.” James’s expression did not change, but something in his eyes grew warmer, more direct. “Because as Richard pointed out, a marriage between our families would be advantageous. And because the existence of that letter has made me realize I can no longer afford to wait for a more convenient moment that may never come.”

The honesty of it struck her harder than any polished speech could have done. She had expected deflection, teasing, the careful distance he had maintained for years. She had not expected this quiet, deliberate declaration of intent. But she would not marry anyone simply to align families. Typical Richard to order her life as if she had no voice of her own. She thought she’d displayed her displeasure at her brother’s interference by rejecting any man he put forward.

But rejecting James would be difficult. He was the man she wanted but she wanted his heart not some cold arrangement.

“And if I refuse?”

“Then I will keep the letter until Christmas Eve, as promised. But I will only return it once you tell me who wrote it. If not, I’ll hand it to your brother.”

Beth looked down at her hands. The rational part of her mind insisted she should refuse—should insist on the immediate return of the letter and the restoration of the careful, distant relationship they had maintained for years. The rest of her—the part that had watched him across rooms for half a decade and never quite managed to look away—hesitated, caught between fear and a dangerous, rising hope.

“Very well,” she said at last, the words feeling both inevitable and terrifying. “You may call. But do not expect me to encourage you.” She smiled like a snake. “And just so you know. I won’t marry any man until I own his heart. Did my brother tell you that?”

James smiled then, and the effect was devastating—a genuine, unguarded curve of the mouth that transformed the sharp lines of his face into something warmer and far more dangerous. “Then I expect only the chance to make you fall in love with me. That is all I ask.”

He did not rise to leave. Instead he settled back in the chair, crossed one booted ankle over his knee, and regarded her with the unhurried attention of a man who had all afternoon and intended to use every minute of it.

“Since I am to court you,” he said, “I had better begin properly. Tell me, Beth. What do you want for Christmas?”

The question was so unexpected that she laughed. “My letter.”

“Besides the letter.”

“Nothing. I have everything I need.”

“Need and want are entirely different creatures.” He tilted his head. “Every lady in London has a list. Lady Harrington, I am reliably informed, has already sent hers to half the shops in Bond Street, with Richard’s direction written at the bottom.”

That surprised another laugh out of her, and she saw the corner of his mouth lift as though he had won a small point and meant to keep score.

“A list would be very dull,” she said. “Gloves. A new reticule. Some trinket I would admire for a week and then put in a drawer.”

“Then tell me something that is not dull.”

She ought to have deflected. She had spent years perfecting the art of saying nothing at all in the most charming manner possible. But the fire was warm, and the room was quiet, and he was looking at her as though the answer genuinely mattered to him.

“Snow,” she said at last. “On Christmas morning. When I was a girl we were always in the country for Christmas, and I would wake before anyone else and run to the window to see if it had fallen in the night. In London it is never the same. It turns grey before breakfast.” She hesitated, then went on more quietly. “And I should like… to be allowed to choose something for myself. Just once. Without anyone deciding it for me first.”

James went very still. For a moment the only sound was the tick of the mantel clock.

“That,” he said slowly, “is not a wish one can wrap in silver paper.”

“No. Which is why I do not expect to receive it.”

He studied her face with an intensity that made her want to look away, and she did not. “Is that why you have refused them all?”

Beth’s chin came up. “Refused whom?”

“Do not play the innocent with me, Beth. I have known you too long. Seven offers in two Seasons, by Richard’s count. Lord Ashworth. Sir Henry Pell. That earnest young man with the estate in Yorkshire and the unfortunate whiskers⁠—”

“Mr. Fairbourne’s whiskers were not his fault.”

“They were entirely his fault. He grew them.”James’s voice gentled. “Every one of them was eligible. Several of them were even tolerable company. And you sent each one away with that polite little smile of yours that tells a man he has been weighed and found wanting. I have wondered why for a long time.”