Page 31
"I'm not asking for your business. I don't care about your business. I care that you moved tables."
"Then I'll sit at the window." She turns her wrist over and looks at a watch she isn't reading.
"That's not what I said."
"It's exactly what you said."
"No." I put both hands on the back of a chair because otherwise they're going to start opening and closing. "What I said was that four days ago you started behaving like a woman who thinks she's being followed, and I'd like to know if she is."
"Would that change anything you do?"
"It would change where I park."
That gets me half a second. Her eyes come up and there's actually a flash of the other thing in there, the amusement, the corner of the mouth, and she puts it away so fast I could almost believe I invented it.
"Nobody is following me," she says.
"That's a very exact sentence."
"It's an accurate one."
"You're allowed to just say I can't tell you." My hands close on the chair back.
"I can't tell you." She says it flat, immediately, with nothing behind it. "There. Has that helped?"
And it hasn't. That's the maddening part. It's the first straight answer she's given me in twenty minutes and it's got less in it than any of the evasions did.
We stand in that kitchen at three in the afternoon, eight feet apart, both of us very quiet.
Here's what I actually understand while it's happening, which is more than I usually get.
I'm not going to win this. Not because she's better at it, though she is. Because there's nothing to win. She hasn't lied to me. She has not told me one thing that is not true in two weeks, which is more than I can say for most people I've dated. She's also told me approximately nothing, and those two facts fit together perfectly. I can't get a fingernail in between them anywhere.
She lives in a world where a man walks up to you at a hospital benefit and says four pleasant sentences that all have a second meaning. You rearrange your evening around it, and you don't explain it to anyone because explaining is how you die. And I live in a world where the worst thing that happens is a building, and buildings are simple, and I have never once in my life had to think about who was in the lobby.
I know which of those two worlds is the real one for most people. It's mine. Hers is the strange one.
Standing in that kitchen, hers doesn't feel strange. That's the part that puts a cold spot under my ribs.
"I don't like being managed," I say.
"I know."
"You do it constantly."
"I do it to everyone. It's not an insult; it's the only way I know how to be in a room." She unfolds her arms. "I'd stop if I could."
"Would you?"
"No," she says. "Probably not."
And that's so plainly honest, after twenty minutes of the other thing, that it takes the legs out from under me.
Neither of us leaves.
That's the fact of the afternoon. There's a version of this where I pick up my keys and leave one flat line behind me on my way out, go home, sit in my apartment with the TV on, and win. It's available to me the entire time, and I'm aware of it the way you're aware of a door.
She's leaning back against the counter with her hands behind her on the edge of it and there's a mark on her throat from three nights ago that she's stopped bothering to cover in her own house, and she's watching me decide, and she isn't helping.