AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Monster You Made of Me

Page 49

by Ellie Sanders

“Nothing,” Eve repeats, tasting the word. She stops directly in front of me, so close I can smell the herbs on her skin, the smoke in her hair. “Why are you lying to me, Skyla?”

Before I can respond, her hand shoots out and connects with my cheek in a sharp, ringing slap that snaps my head to the side. Pain explodes across my face, and I taste the blood where my teeth cut into the inside of my mouth.

“I asked you a question.” Eve’s voice doesn’t rise. She doesn’t need to raise it. “Do you lie to me?”

I force myself to straighten, to meet her eyes even as my cheek throbs. “No, Eve. I would never…”

But she’s already moved past me. Her attention has shifted fully to Winnie, who has pressed herself back against the shelving, her eyes wide with fear. Eve moves fast, faster than should be possible for a woman her age, and suddenly her hand is around Winnie’s throat, fingers pressing into the soft skin.

“Tell me,” Eve says conversationally, as if she’s asking about the weather and not cutting off another woman’s air supply. “Why do you look so upset, little Winnie? Why are there tears on your face when you should be rejoicing?”

Winnie makes a choking sound, her hands coming up to claw at Eve’s wrist. But Eve’s grip doesn’t budge.

“Eve, please…” I start forward, but Cait catches my arm, holding me back. Her grip is iron, her face carefully blank. A warning.

“I’m waiting.” Eve’s fingers tighten fractionally.

“I’m, I’m pregnant!” The words burst from Winnie’s mouth in a desperate gasp. “I’m pregnant and Danny is the father!”

The room erupts.

Suddenly the women are no longer frozen statues but living, breathing things again, their voices rising in a cacophony of joy and excitement. They surge forward, surrounding us, their hands reaching for Winnie. A pregnancy. A child. This is what we work for, what we pray for. New life. New blood. Of course, it would be better for our champion to have fathered her child, but a child is a child, nonetheless.

“A baby!” Kinslee cries, clapping her hands together.

“Blessed be,” Simone breathes, her eyes shining.

But I can’t join in their celebration. I’m watching Eve’s face, watching the way her expression hasn’t changed, hasn’t softened. She’s released Winnie’s throat, but she hasn’t stepped back, hasn’t given her space to breathe.

And Winnie…

Winnie’s face has transformed. The fear is still there, but it’s been joined by something else now. Something fierce and desperate and dangerous.

“Danny is the father,” she says again, louder this time. Her voice cuts through the celebration, silencing it. “Danny. Do you hear me? And you won’t, I won’t let you…” She’s snarling now, her teeth bared, her hands clenched into fists at her sides. “You won’t murder him. Any of you. I won’t let you.”

The silence that falls is absolute.

No. No, Winnie, don’t…

Eve tilts her head slightly, considering. Then she shakes it slowly, almost sadly, the way a parent might shake their head at a particularly foolish child.

I wince, anticipating what’s coming. My cheek still throbs from her slap, a reminder of what defiance costs.

“Oh, Winnie.” Eve’s voice is silken, dangerous. “You forget yourself.”

“I don’t…” Winnie starts, but Eve speaks over her.

“You forget where you are. Who you belong to. What your place is.” She turns, addressing the room now, her voice rising. “This will be a lesson. For Winnie. For all of you. For the entire commune.” Her eyes sweep across each woman, holding their gazes one by one. “We do not defy the natural order. We do not place our individual desires above the collective good. We do not…” she turns back to Winnie, “…threaten our sisters.”

Then she snaps her fingers.

The sound is sharp and final, like a bone breaking.

Two women I don’t recognize immediately move forward from the doorway…they must have entered with Eve, must have been waiting. Strong women, older, their faces hard with purpose. They grab Winnie’s arms, one on each side.

“No!” Winnie’s scream splits the air, raw and animal. She fights against them, thrashing violently, but they’re too strong. They drag her backward toward the door, while her feet scrabble for purchase on the stone floor. “No! Please! Skyla! Skyla, help me!”

I lurch forward, but Cait’s hand is on my arm, and this time others join her. Gentle hands. Restraining hands. Holding me in place.