Page 37
“By…?” He jabs a thumb at his chest.
I give him a half-shrug and his brows shoot up under the thick curls spilling over his forehead.
“You’re kind of a man of mystery in the local food scene.”
“Man of mystery?” He asks against the lip of his glass. “That’s a bit dramatic, isn’t it?”
“Is it? I mean, you’re practically a household name in our industry but until today I don’t think I could have listed one thing about you, beyond the generic stuff.”
“Such as?”
“You know. The usual stuff people say about you.” I shrug again when he only looks at me blankly, and count off on my fingers. “You’re talented, you’re a hard ass, you’re…”
He lifts his brows expectantly.
Damn it.
“You’re… you know.” I wave my hand in his direction.
“Is there an end to that sentence, or…”
I sigh. “You’re – people seem to think you’re… rather attractive. Or something.”
Theo chokes on his beer. “I’m known for this?” He asks between coughs, wiping his eyes with the back of his arm. “Fucking hell, something’s gone seriously wrong if that’s true. I’ve been named Chef to Watch in Time to Dine six times, for fuck’s sake. And this is what people retain?”
And he looks so appalled that a laugh bursts out of me. The sound seems to startle him. He freezes, brows shooting up again, probably realizing like I just have that this is the first time I’ve laughed at his joke and not his expense.
I clear my throat awkwardly just as our server drops fresh drinks on the table, collecting our empty glasses.
“Thanks,” Theo tells her, grabbing his new pint with his eyes still on me. He chews on his cheek for a second. “Why is it you hate me, again?”
The question is so out of the blue it gives me whiplash.
“Have we forgotten about a certain voicemail –”
He has the grace to flinch at the mention. “Right, that’s fair. But is that it?”
The look he gives me says there’s nothing rhetorical about the question.
“Again, I’m compelled to ask: Is this a trap?”
“No, it’s not a trap. I’m curious. Tell me what you think of me, voicemail aside.”
I shift uncomfortably in my seat. “Look, I’m sure you can be nice enough –”
But he cuts me off with an impatient wave of his hand. “Don’t bullshit me. If there’s one thing about you, Holland, it’s that you don’t seem to live with an incessant need to sugarcoat like ninety-nine percent of the population. Don’t start now.”
“I’ll take that as a compliment.”
“It is a compliment. Come on,” he motions at his chest. “Hit me with your worst.”
I sit back in my chair with a hard look at him, wary of the direction we’re going but a little emboldened by the whiskey sour running through my veins. “Okay, I’ll play. For one, there’s this thing you do when you walk. This kind of strut with a perma-scowl like you own every inch of the floor you’re crossing.”
He frowns. “What else?”
“There’s the fourth thing people tend to say about you. That you’re… generally unpleasant. And I’ve seen you tear into people for simple mistakes.”
“Such as?”