Page 33
I expect him to give me that smile now that he’s getting his way. The big one. The Finn smile. But only a single corner of his mouth ticks up. He gives me a lingering look before turning to the fridge. “Good. Great.”
Chapter 8
Finn
I follow the smell of cumin and cheese into the kitchen to find Jenna seated on the counter, grinning down at her phone. Her forever-long legs are folded underneath her, neat and delicate in a way I could never pull off even though she’s pretty much as tall as I am.
And I know it’s not right to stare, that I have no right to stare when I’ve asked her for platonic. But her hair is a little wild around her shoulders tonight, falling in every direction, and there’s something so endearing in the way her neck curves to the side as she thinks. In the way her shoulders shudder as she laughs silently to herself.
We haven’t been avoiding each other, not exactly. I slept in this morning, and she left me a note saying she was meeting Jude for lunch, and then I went out for a run and…
I clear my throat. “Hey.”
Jenna does a double take, almost fumbling her phone. She gives me a tentative smile. “Hey.”
She crosses an arm over her stomach to clasp her other elbow, and something’s different. With her, but with me, too. Things have shifted since last night’s Scout’s honor. It’s a little delicate. As though we’re only just meeting now.
I’m nervous, I realize. Even after deciding I wouldn’t sleep with her, the idea of it was still there. A possibility. We mesh when we flirt. What does this—what do we—look like without sex and overt flirtation?
Pink stains her cheeks. “Okay. I think we’ve been staring at each other longer than normal.”
My chuckle is half-laugh, half the expulsion of a breath I didn’t realize I’ve been holding. I nod to her phone and move to sort through the cupboard over the fridge for a fresh bag of turtle pellets. “You looked like you were plotting someone’s untimely demise. And may I casually remind you that I pay the rent in this place, so it better not be mine.”
“I’m a trust fund baby, remember?” She laughs. “You’re definitely not off the hook. But I will once again thank you for covering my half of the rent and remind you that you can change your mind about that at any time. Seriously, I feel the feminism seep out of me every time I think about it.”
“I’m not taking your money. But I will put you to work if you want me to.” I jiggle the bag of turtle pellets and tip my head toward the living room. “Wanna help me feed Eddie?”
Oh.
I’ve seen this girl smile and smirk and laugh her head off, but that look? The way her entire body seems to brighten, light up from within at the suggestion of feeding my pet turtle?
It’s pure magic.
“I get to feed him?” she says, bouncing off the kitchen counter and following close behind me as we cross the space to the tank on the far wall.
“Get to? You’re telling me you’ve been harboring a secret turtle caretaking fetish this whole time? Why didn’t you say anything?”
“I don’t know,” she says with a laugh. “I saw you passed out together on the sofa last night. He’s your baby. It felt kind of like asking to wear a prizefighter’s belt, or something.”
I throw her a grin over my shoulder. “I’m big on cuddles, what can I say? They don’t come around often when you live alone.”
I catch it. The way she opens her mouth and snaps it shut. If I ever learn she was about to offer up cuddles, I’m gonna hate myself for this platonic thing.
Jenna sidles up to me and together we peer into Eddie’s tank. The turtle is completely unconcerned with us. He lounges on a rock in the corner of his tank, neck stretched out towards the water like he’s contemplating his next move.
“So all he eats are these pellets?” she asks, tentatively reaching down to run the back of her finger along Eddie’s shell.
“Well, turtles are omnivores—” I cut myself off. I’m on the verge of waxing poetic on the dietary preferences of turtles and if Nina were here she’d give me that snarky look she does whenever I get too National Geographic on her.
Jenna dips her finger into the water, as though checking its temperature. “Meaning you feed Eddie pellets with a side of filet mignon and broccoli?”
“He tends to prefer collard greens. Worms, if he’s been a good boy.”
“Well, you must get a ton of worms then, don’t you, Eddie?”
Her voice goes all soft and cooey, and fuck—something searing hot blows up in my chest. She wasn’t faking being into the pet turtle thing the night she showed up.
Where did this woman come from, exactly?