Page 94
“Please tell me they include the year Iris gave Finn the bowl cut.”
He does it again. Dad chuckles. “You heard about the bowl cut, huh? Well, you’re in luck, young lady.”
A moment later we watch them stream through the opposed archway into the living room. Jenna’s got an arm threading through Dad’s.
What—
“What the hell was that?” I turn to Hayls, searching her face for answers even though, if I can stop lying to myself for just one second, I know exactly what the hell that was.
“We screwed up big, didn’t we?” Hayley says, putting her own pieces together. Admitting to her own lies. She isn’t whispering. The tap’s still running and they’re in the other room now, but it still feels like something big.
I shove my glasses on top of my head, pressing my palms to my eyes. “I thought it would make it worse.”
Did I? Because in this moment, it feels like I’ve been fooling myself. Keeping Mom out of my mouth was for Dad’s sake. But also maybe for mine, and how bad it hurts to think about her sometimes, and how happy we were together in this home. So, I did the only thing I could think of: pretended she didn’t exist, every time I came here.
Lying about my feelings. I’m really good at that, aren’t I?
“We screwed up so fucking big, Hayls.”
She wipes her eyes. “Where the hell did you find this girl?”
“Finding her wasn’t the hard part.”
I feel lost, and blown away, and confused, and a little bit mad at myself and how much time I’ve wasted. We could have had Dad back. He was sitting right there, aching to remember her.
Jenna’s tinkling laugh floats from the other room. It feels like a life vest. I cling to it.
Hayls winds an arm around me, wrapping me in a tight hug. “Jump, big brother.”
Chapter 19
Jenna
I think I screwed up.
The top of the Jeep is off, and we speed down the freeway in the direction of home. Metallica is blasting around us. It’s like all our other joyrides of the past couple months. And yet, it’s not.
Finn isn’t singing along at the top of his voice, the way he usually does. Tonight, he stares fixedly through the windshield. He hasn’t said a word since we left his dad’s, and there’s a real chance me and my stupid inability to just let things be made a hard day even worse.
After dinner, he sat quietly in an armchair watching Hayley and I huddle on the living room floor poring over old photo albums, his dad piping in every so often with a new anecdote about the kids growing up.
I’d meet his eye occasionally, but he only returned my tentative smiles with a barely-there lift to the corner of his mouth.
It didn’t feel wrong, talking about Iris. Vince’s eyes lit up the second I pointed out that photo in the dining room. And after only a few minutes, his face changed. Not just his expression, but the shape of it. His cheeks rose, eyes crinkled. I decided when I first saw him that Finn must favor his mom with his looks. But the second his father smiled, my Finn was there.
No. He’s not your Finn. That’s the point, isn’t it?
I crossed a line. I’m not his girlfriend. I’m a friend to a man who’s struggling to come to terms with his feelings for me. I forgot my place.
I reach for my hair, grabbing randomly at the strands blowing in the wind, trying to tame them as we approach Finn’s apartment building. He winds us down the underground parking, and by the time he pulls into his spot and kills the engine, I’m a bundle of guilty nerves.
It’s just a concrete wall ahead of us now. Still, it seems he’d rather stare at it than look at me.
“Finn—”
“Did I ever tell you one of my instructors at culinary school told me I was so bad I belonged behind the counter at a fast-food joint?”
He says it to the steering wheel, and it takes me a second to catch up with the unexpected direction of this conversation. He’s gearing up for a Finn story, one of my favorite things in the world. They’re the kind that seem random, out of the blue, until he finishes and you realize he’s told you exactly what you needed to hear. Normally, I’d let go and enjoy the ride, see where he takes me. This time, I’m so nervous I wish I knew where we were going.