AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The No-Judgment Zone

Page 96

by Ellie K. Wilde

It’s that burning feeling in my throat. The good one. “Relationship?”

“I can’t promise I’ll always know what I’m doing, and I think you’re gonna have to ease me into it. But I wanna give it a shot. My best shot.” He runs his thumb along my palm. “And I’m already screwing it up. Because the very least I could have done is tell you all this literally anywhere other than an underground parking garage, but…” He shrugs helplessly.

I lean in, place a kiss on his cheek. “I wouldn’t change it.”

His chest swells at the words. “I wouldn’t change you. Not a single thing. You know that?”

I melt in my seat like a swirl of soft-serve ice cream settling into itself, strawberry with a twist of ecstasy. For half a second I feel myself trying to play it cool. Casual. Giving him a moment to claw it all back if he wants to. But it doesn’t stick. My face breaks and his does too, giving me that crooked grin I love, so big I wonder whether his cheeks hurt. We sit there smiling at each other like a pair of giddy kids, dumbstruck by our good fortune.

“I’m so sorry about last night,” Finn tells me, smile not dropping an inch. “I think if delusion had a mascot, it would be me.”

I laugh. “I think I might have you beat in that department. I don’t even want to tell you what I thought I had to do to win you over.”

The furrow in his brow only lasts a second. “The turtleneck?” His head falls back in a loud laugh when I nod. “Yeah, okay. You win. That was peak delusion. I took one look at you that night and thought I’d died and gone to hell.”

“I was in hell. Do you know how itchy it was under there?”

“That settles it. We’re going up there to burn it.” He brings up my hand to kiss it. “I’m sorry we spent our first date with my family. And that my idea for our second date isn’t much better.”

“What is it?”

“I want to come with you this Saturday. To your sister’s wedding. I know it’s a terrible faux pas, inviting myself to a stranger’s wedding. But the thought of you there alone kind of makes me want to hurl up my tofu.”

Can he hear that high-pitched squeal in my head? I wouldn’t care if he did.

“I really want that. The wedding date, not the hurling. Just so we’re clear.”

The wattage from his smile could power an entire hemisphere. “Look at me go. Who says the over-sexualized himbo can’t get the girl?”

I press my lips together, terrified the size of my smile will cause permanent muscle damage. “The same people who say the sexed-up pony can’t get the guy.”

“The sexed-up—”

“Trust me, you don’t want to know,” I say, and I reach to smooth the crinkle in his brow. “Should we go upstairs?”

With his gaze on me, Finn gives a slow nod. All my senses heighten. I don’t know what upstairs means for us, after the things we did together the other night. After I spent last night in his bed.

God, I hope he kisses me tonight.

Upstairs, Finn watches as I dig my keys out of my purse. He’s being uncharacteristically quiet, but he doesn’t take his eyes off me either. Under that stare, every bit of me feels alive. Aware. Whatever he gives me when I open this door, I want it. Finn sweeps the hair off my shoulder and I fumble my keys.

I turn and he gives me a soft smile, taking in the burning in my cheeks. “See how good you are at this?” I tell him. “It’s only the first date and I can barely keep my cool.”

I finally get the lock open, but before I can open the door he tugs my hand.

“Wait.”

He’s standing so close. So close his foot tucks in between mine, hand barely needs to pull at my hip to press me against him, turn my back into the door. He’s clenching his jaw, eyes heavy when he says: “I have a confession.”

I shiver as the pad of his thumb strokes my waist. “What is it?”

Finn’s gaze cuts to my mouth, and the way he licks his lips makes me squirm against the door. “I kiss on the first date.”

I breathe out a startled laugh and he grins at the sound of it. I fist his shirt, pull him closer so that we’re chest to chest. Pounding heart to pounding heart.

“I love that about you,” I murmur.

Finn slides a hand around my waist, fingers spreading over my lower back, holding me tight to him.