Page 43
Blushing furiously, I do my best to ignore him and the way he (possibly) just checked me out, and instead announce the start of the tour. Think nun thoughts, I tell myself as I roll through my usual welcome spiel. Rosary beads. Praying. Whatever the fuck else nuns do.
Just… not Benny.
Literally anything but the hot FBPI man who’s lingering near the back of the group, his gaze fixed intently on me while I shuffle everybody toward the doors.
The first stop on the tour is usually Northgate, but tonight, I can’t think of a place I’d rather be less than the Burial Grounds. Besides, there’s still crime scene tape up. And while I’m sure that a bunch of influencers and curious tourists have already found ways to sneak in among the gravestones, I’m not about to feed into the growing hysteria.
No, Northgate is not on tonight’s bingo card.
Instead, I walk us half a block farther down the sidewalk and stop us outside the Tomb Witch Museum. But before I can even start reciting my script for the location, a teenage-looking kid standing with a couple that I guess are his parents shouts out, “Hey, do you think the Tomb Witch really murdered those people?”
Some tourists gasp, while others giggle. The possibly-parents roll their eyes.
I fight the urge to do the same.
Something, something, professionalism.
So, instead, I slap on my best this-is-fine smile and say, “Let’s keep murder off the menu tonight, please.”
Somebody snorts loudly, and my gaze narrows in on Benny. Was that him? I can’t tell. There are too many people in the group, and the crowd around us is loud. It’s making me nervous. And the memory of the murders—blood on the grass, limbs everywhere, the umbrella—is stuck replaying behind it all now that the kid mentioned it, and my heart races as the first prickles of adrenaline sink their claws into me, and my mouth tastes like old blood, and…
“What’s the Tomb Witch, anyway?” a voice calls from the back. “It sounds like somebody’s shitty metal garage band.”
Okay, that was definitely Benny. And when I make eye contact with him, he doesn’t just smirk—he winks at me.
Fucking winks.
It’s goofy as hell, and this time, my smile is small but genuine.
Is he trying to distract me? Is the way I’m about to totally lose my shit that apparent? Because he knows exactly what the Tomb Witch is, given the stupid joke he made earlier, and I can’t think of why else he’d try to derail the whole murder thing.
Drawing in a deep breath, I do my best to keep my voice even as I play along and segue into my practiced script. “The Tomb Witch is a local legend, said to be the restless spirit of a witch who was sealed alive in a crypt for practicing dark magic. While some people insist that she was real, no evidence of her true identity has ever been found. However, that doesn’t mean that there isn’t any accuracy to her story. Back in the late 1600s, several women in Salwick were tried for witchcraft, including Goody Northgate, after whom the Burial Grounds were later named.”
And then, I’m back.
Normal.
Fine, even.
The rest of the tour runs smoothly, even though I can still feel Benny’s eyes lingering on me with each second that passes. Seriously, does the man ever blink? It should be unsettling. But there’s something about him that just makes it… not.
Intense? Yes.
Creepy? No.
By the time we make it back to the museum, I’m the usual amount of exhausted, but not quite ready to call it a night. That might have something to do with the cute guy who’s leaning against the counter.
Okay, it has everything to do with that.
He waits patiently as I answer questions and herd the rest of the visitors out the doors, all while hoping that none of them end up dead tonight.
Was that nightmare a one-off? Some freak occurrence of nature or something?
A girl can dream, I guess.
And then finally, it’s done.
The only ones left in the museum are Benny and me.