Page 104
I groan into his chest.
“Do you have plans on New Year’s Eve?” he asks.
“Blaire is having a party at her cabin on the mountain. Involves a bonfire and casting intention spells for the new year,” I tell him.
He laughs. “Ever thought about spending it in New York?”
“I can’t, Thatcher. But I really appreciate the invite,” I tell him.
“If you change your mind …”
“I’ll let you know,” I say.
I hold on to him a little tighter. He kisses the top of my head and pulls the blankets up over us. Eventually, his breathing slows. I listen to it, knowing that we have fifteen days left and it won’t be enough. But I’m scared to death of where it will go from here.
I can’t sleep.
Sometime around midnight, I slip out from under his arm. On my way past the studio, I grab his sweater off the floor and pull it on. It smells like him. I move into the kitchen and preheat the oven because the dough has been in the fridge for hours.
I scoop a dozen of each onto two trays lined with parchment paper. While they bake, I sit at the counter with my knees pulled up under the knitted sweater. Sleet slaps against the windows.
The kitchen smells like cinnamon and brown sugar.
Eventually, Thatcher enters with his hair flat on one side. “Cookies at midnight?”
“I couldn’t sleep,” I admit.
He doesn’t ask why. Instead, he joins me at the island. He wraps his arm around me as we watch the timer. When it goes off, I remove the tray from the oven. I put the cookies on cooling racks.
Thatcher reaches for one, and I smack his hand.
“Wait just a few minutes. They’ll fall apart and burn the roof of your mouth.”
“Ugh,” he says, then grins.
Once I can pick them up without burning the top layer of skin off, I break one of each in half. We hold half of each one in our hands.
He blows on the chocolate chip first and eats it with his eyes closed. “So gooey.”
Then he tries the oatmeal raisin, chewing and swallowing it.
“Hmm.” He goes between both until there’s nothing but crumbs on his fingers. “Sorry, I can’t decide.”
I reach for him, tickling his side. Laughter falls out of him as I chase him around the kitchen. “Tell me!”
He snatches one of each off the wire racks.
On the next circle around, I grab the camera and snap a photo of him. “Any last words?”
“Can’t it be a tie?” he asks.
I take another photo. “No. There is only one clear winner.”
“I can’t choose,” he admits, eating a third oatmeal cookie. “I’m still deciding.”
I wave the pictures, waiting for them to develop. Thatcher is the only thing that comes into focus. There are cookies in his hands and guilt on his face. I stick them to the fridge, next to our others.
“Evidence that you ate more oatmeal raisin than chocolate chips,” I tell him.