Secret Baby For My Brother’s Best Friend
Page 116
The words land exactly as hard as I expect them to and somehow still worse.
"Okay," I say, my voice gone small. "I understand that."
"Do you?" he asks, something bitter creeping into his tone now. "Because I don't think you do, Iris. I think you understand that I'm hurt. I don't think you understand what it's like to find out you missed more than two years of your own kid's life because someone decided you weren't strong enough to hear the truth."
"That's not what I decided," I say, my voice shaking now despite everything I do to hold it steady.
"Then what did you decide?" he whisper-shouts, stepping closer, his hands opening at his sides like he doesn't know what to do with them. "Walk me through it. What exactly was the decision, if it wasn't that?"
I stand there for a second, my whole chest burning with everything I've held back for three years, every justification I built and rebuilt in the dark while he was four hundred miles away building a life he thought was only his to build.
"Tell me something," I say, and my voice comes out steadier now, sharper, something in me finally done apologizing for a decision I made out of love instead of malice. "If I had told you. If I'd called you the week I found out and said I'm pregnant, would you have gone to law school anyway?"
His jaw works, and he looks away toward the window instead of answering right away.
"Answer me," I press. "Would you have gone?"
"I would have gone somewhere closer," he says finally, his voice rough. "Boston, maybe. Somewhere I could drive home on weekends."
"When?" I ask, stepping closer now, refusing to let him retreat into the vague comfort of a hypothetical he never actually had to live inside. "When would that have happened, Dom? Tell me exactly. Would you have deferred while I was still postpartum, bleeding and exhausted and figuring out how to keep a newborn alive on three hours of sleep? Would you have stayed through her first year, missed your orientation, watched me hand Maggie the bakery keys because I couldn't run it and nurse a baby at the same time?"
"Iris. "
"Or later," I keep going, my voice climbing now, years of held-back grief finally finding the door. "When she started pre-K. Would that have been the right time to chase your dream, once she was old enough to ask why Daddy left? Or high school, maybe. College. At what exact point in her life would it have ever felt okay to you to choose something for yourself and let her be the cost of it?"
He doesn't answer.
"Because I need you to sit with that question," I tell him as my voice cracks. "I made the hardest version of that choice so you would never have to. I loved you enough to let you become the man you wanted to be, even if it made you a stranger to your own daughter. Do not tell me I do not understand what it cost."
His face runs through everything at once, I watch it happen in real time, fury and grief and something that looks dangerously close to understanding, all of it fighting for the same few inches of space behind his eyes, and for one long second I actually believe he's about to say something that might crack this whole standoff open.
"That still wasn't your decision to make," he says instead, low and final, like he's reached the bottom of whatever argument he was carrying and found only that one sentence still standing.
"No," I agree, my voice gone quiet now, all the fight drained out of it at once. "Maybe it wasn't. But it was the only one I had."
He looks at me for one more long moment, something unreadable moving behind his eyes, and then he turns and walks toward the front door, his hand finding the knob before I can find another word to stop him with.
"I'll pick her up Thursday," he says, not turning around. "Like we talked about."
"Okay," I whisper, though I'm not sure he hears it.
The door closes behind him with a soft, ordinary click, no slam, no drama, just the quiet, devastating sound of a man leaving a house he still clearly wants to stay in, and I stand alone in my own front hall with my arms wrapped around myself, listening to his truck start in the driveway and pull away, the sound fading slow into the ordinary afternoon outside like nothing at all has happened here.
Down the hall, the sound machine hums on, and somewhere beneath its steady white noise, our daughter sleeps through all of it, completely unaware that both of her parents just stood twenty feet from her crib and broke each other open all over again.
31
DOMINIC
A week into learning how to be a father who actually shows up, and I've discovered there's an entire universe of things about my own daughter I don't know yet, filed somewhere between which stuffed animal she'll actually sleep with and how she takes her scrambled eggs, which turns out to be dry, no ketchup, a preference she communicated to me with a look of such profound betrayal the one time I got it wrong that I haven't risked it since.
"Oc-tus," Winter announces from the shopping cart, both arms stretched toward a shelf of stuffed animals like she's about to be physically separated from her destiny.
"You said that about the last three things," I tell her, pushing the cart closer anyway, because apparently I'm the kind of father who negotiates with a toddler and loses every single time.
She reaches for a purple octopus with oversized felt eyes and clutches it to her chest the second it's in range, making a small, satisfied sound that goes straight through me, and I have to stop and just look at her for a second, the curve of her cheek, the exact shade of her eyes, the way her curls do that same stubborn thing mine did at that age according to every photo my mother ever kept. She looks so much like me it's almost funny, like someone took the worst parts of my childhood pictures and made them work on a face this small.
"You're going to bankrupt me one stuffed animal at a time," I tell her, and she responds by shoving the octopus's tentacle directly into my face, which I choose to interpret as an apology.