AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Tell Me It’s Wrong

Page 87

by Katie Wismer

And it’s difficult to tell in this lighting, but I swear his pupils are a little dilated now.

Yeah, definitely worth it.

His usual carefree grin finally makes an appearance as he steps back and holds the door open. He presses a hand to the small of my back as I pass.

“You look…I don’t have words. Truly,” he murmurs.

I bump his chest with my shoulder. “Back at you. Smells amazing in here.”

His smile widens as he leads me to the kitchen. “Word on the street is you appreciate a good chili and baked potato combo.”

“Oh, the street, huh?”

He shrugs. “Casey.”

A stupid smile fights its way onto my face at the sight of the table—draped with a tablecloth I’ve never seen him use, and perfectly set with two places, along with a single rose in a vase and three flickering candlesticks. Faint instrumental music trickles from somewhere.

Fletcher gestures for me to take the seat at the head of the table as he uncorks a bottle of wine. His eyes dart from me to the glass as he pours. “Is this too much?”

I blow the air out of my cheeks as I take the glass from him. “That depends. Did you make dessert too?”

He glances sideways at the kitchen, and I laugh.

“That part’s store-bought, if it helps.”

“Can I do anything?”

He shakes his head and squeezes my shoulder as he passes. “No, just sit tight. Should be ready in a few minutes.”

I turn my chair, sip my wine, and watch shamelessly as he bends over to check the oven. He rolls up his sleeves before pulling out the pan, and I am in heat.

I might not make it through dinner.

It’s been two months since that first night in the hotel—not that I’m keeping track. My thighs involuntarily press together, and I quickly cross them. As Fletcher removes the oven mitts, his eyes find my leg—namely, the good deal of thigh showing from the slit in my dress. I smile a little as he quickly looks away. So the stockings were a good call.

“So,” he says. “I’ve been meaning to ask you about next week…”

I dig in my eyebrows. Next week?

“Is it not your birthday?” he asks.

Oh. Oh. I picture a calendar in my head. Yeah, I guess he’s right.

He laughs in disbelief. “Did you forget?”

I shrug. “Well…yeah.”

It’s not like there hasn’t been plenty else going on. And I’ve never been a fan of my birthday to begin with. I’ve spent most of them alone. My mom didn’t believe in birthday cakes—said they weren’t worth the calories. And I didn’t exactly have a lot of friends to invite for a party.

A look I can’t read passes over Fletcher’s face. “Well, I’d understand if you wanted to keep it with just you and Case or something, but if you’d be okay with me being there…”

“Of course I want you there, Fletch. Just—we really don’t need to make a big deal of it or anything, okay?”

He nods, his lips pressed together like he’s suppressing a smile. “Understood.”

Once everything’s ready, he brings over our plates and takes the seat beside me. It is, unsurprisingly, one of the best things I’ve ever tasted—as everything he makes seems to be.

“Where did you learn to cook like this?” I ask between bites, though it’s difficult to hold back from shoveling the entire plate into my mouth.