Page 70
He shook his head. “I asked, but she didn’t want to jinx it. Seeing as you know who is always watching.”
I blew out a breath. “She asked him to find her a home, someone to call family.”
Eli let out a matching breath. “Shit.”
“Yeah, shit. I’m going to have to figure something out. I just wanted her to believe in Santa so she could get some of her youth back.”
He scratched at the beard growing in. “Weird thing was that when Kris was at Hanover last—”
“Kris stopped by Hanover?”
“Aunt Francine invited him for casserole night.”
“And you were there too?” Sometimes Eli would come with me before games for lunch, but dinner on his own was a new one.
“I just told you it was casserole night. What part of that sentence aren’t you understanding? Aunt Francine knows her way around a baking dish.”
I rolled my eyes at him. “Dude, we seriously need to find you a woman.”
“Shut up. She puts those crunchy onion things on top. It reminds me of what my grandma used to make. I’m not going to apologize for eating good food when it’s offered.”
“Fine, fine. Back to whatever Kris was doing on casserole night.”
“When Susan asked him how her gift was coming along, he said things are shaping up nicely and winked at her.” Eli swiped to a selfie he’d taken with Susan. “Shaping up nicely. What’s that supposed to mean?”
“I don’t know. Maybe someone out there has been thinking about adopting her. She’s adorable, and the team did use her in a lot of publicity for the Series. Probably some person out there looking for a kid to fill a hole in their heart fell in love with her. The cute little ones always go first.” It was a sad truth. I tried not to think too hard about how many times young me had to swallow my disappointment.
“You really think Susan is getting adopted?” His brows knit together. For some reason he looked worried by that statement.
“I mean. It’s possible. I don’t know why Kris would know about it. I feel like Francine would have said something if there were papers in motion, but yeah, maybe.” I tilted my head in confusion. “Why do you look like you just got jump scared? It’s not like you were thinking about adopting her.”
“Yeah…” He barked out a breathy laugh. “I mean. I wouldn’t be opposed to it.”
I blinked at him in surprise. Adopting a kid was a big step, especially for a single guy in our line of work. The hockey schedule was rough on rock solid families. I couldn’t imagine how hard it would be to try and go it alone.
Eli looked down at his phone. It buzzed with an incoming call from Aunt Francine. He smiled, and then some thought clicked in his head to make him smile wider. “I’ve gotta take this.”
I wiped down the press while he chatted with Aunt Francine.
“Of course I’m coming tomorrow,” he said, eyes shifting over to me. “Yeah, he’s coming too. I’m looking right at him. No. He wouldn’t miss lunch. It’s tradition.”
Damn, did she really think I was so in my head that I would miss a game day lunch? I hated that she was concerned enough that she was now recruiting Eli to look after me, even if he didn’t understand that was what she was doing. Francine never could leave me to my devices.
“Noooo.” Eli’s eyes bulged out of his head. “I didn’t know that. No, he didn’t say anything.”
I spent the night pouring out my heart to Aunt Francine, and this was how she repaid me.
He lowered the phone and whisper-hissed at me. “What did you do to Holly?”
“Why does everyone assume it was me?” Cause you’re a fuck up, Colt. That’s why. First Mills, now Eli. After Miller stumbled on Holly crying in her office, he took it upon himself to put me through the inquisition. He was supposed to be my best friend, just like they were supposed to be my team. But then today at practice everyone was taking shots like they were trying to take a chunk out of me.
I wasn’t the one who was too stubborn to check her facts. She was so quick to assume the worst of me. That hurt more than I was ready for. “Ya know, maybe I left her.”
Not a total lie. I did walk out of the room on my own.
Although, I’m still not entirely certain that was the right choice. Especially when Miller told me how he found her. In truth, I did sell our love story. Because I wasn’t a knowing participant didn’t mean I wasn’t in some ways complicit. I think that was what made me so angry about all of this. I couldn’t blame her for being pissed.
Eli chuckled at whatever Aunt Francine said. He turned, slugging me in the shoulder. “Yeah, I’ve seen the movie. It’s one of my favorites, too.”