Page 80
The great council convenes four days later and runs for nine.
Eleven weeks of preparation leave me unprepared, because I made a category error: I assumed the difficulty would be persuading the chiefs to unite, and the difficulty is entirely in what shape.
Everyone agrees, in principle, that eleven tribes standing separately nearly lost the world. Nobody agrees on the arithmetic.
Ynara wants representation weighted by territory, favoring Riverwind’s long stretch of water. Torvak wants it weighted by warriors, which favors Stonefang. Four small clans want strict equality, one voice each, and will not move, and they are correct that any weighting at all makes them permanently irrelevant.
By the fourth day three competing proposals exist, along with a lot of tired shouting.
By the sixth, two hill clans have started using the word withdraw.
That is the point at which I ask Natalie to speak, and she refuses.
“Not to the structure,” she says, in the passage outside, with the argument still audible through the stone. “Kheron, I have no business anywhere near how you weight your own votes. I’d be wrong and I’d be wrong loudly and it would poison everything else I’ve said here.”
“Then speak to something else.”
“To what?”
“To the thing each of them fears and none will name.” I keep hold of her gaze. “They are not arguing about seats. They argue because a shared council lets another’s vote bind their people, and they have four hundred years of reasons to expect that to go badly. Give them a reason that is bigger than the fear.”
She thinks about it for most of an hour.
Then she goes in, and she does not talk about governance at all.
“I’ve been asked to give you the ecological position,” she says, “so I’m going to do that, and it’ll take about six minutes, and then I’ll sit down.
“The interior basin lost three sacred species outright. Along the north wall, eleven hundred hectares of canopy stands dead. The ossira run came within four days of failing, and if it had failed you’d have had nine years with no ossira in the Vaska, which means nine years of the fish that eat them, which means a generation of Riverwind children who grow up not knowing what the river does in the spawning season.
“None of that respected a border. The seep that opened in Chief Torvak’s lower gallery was caused by an excavation in Sunscale range. Kolva that quit migrating through the basin had been feeding the hill clans’ predators, and those predators came into the hill settlements when the herds went north — that’s where your two hunters were killed, Chief Ilsen, and I’m sorry to use them, but you know I’m right.
“Here’s the whole of my testimony.” She sets her hands on the table. “This world is one system. It has run as one system for four hundred thousand years, designed so by people who built a machine that only works if sixteen tribes stand in it at the same time. You are not being asked to unite because uniting is noble. You’re asked because the alternative is eleven separate holds each solving a third of a problem and each failing, and the ground under you does not care about the river bend.
“That’s it. That’s the ecology. What you do about your seats is your business and I’d be an idiot to have an opinion.”
Then she sits down.
Silence holds for some time.
It is Chief Ilsen of the eastern hills — sixty-one years old, two hunters buried, four days into using the word withdraw — who finally speaks.
“Sixteen,” he says. “The stones. There are sixteen.”
“There are,” Varesh agrees.
“And we number eleven.”
“Yes.”
“So five of those alcoves belong to peoples who are gone.” Ilsen looks slowly around that hall. “My clan is four hundred and nine people. Walk out of this council and we become the twelfth. And in four generations somebody stands in a chamber and counts ten.”
He says nothing further all day. There is no need.
We have an agreement by the ninth evening and it is uglier than any of the three proposals and better than all of them.
One voice per tribe, no weighting — the small clans win that outright. But any measure binding a tribe’s own ground requires that tribe’s consent, so nobody can be outvoted onto their own territory. A standing council seated four times a year, at a different hold each time, which was Ynara’s idea and is cleverer than it sounds. And a rotating speakership: one year, no consecutive terms, chosen by lot from the chiefs who have attended every seating.
By lot. That was Kavik, who is now a full warrior with the scars to prove it and who said it aloud in a corridor to nobody in particular, and Ossik heard him and brought it in.