Page 64
Damn it. She would grab that pompom immediately.
I tucked the ridiculous hat under my arm. “Fine. The unicorns win.”
Jensen pulled the charcoal beanie over his hair and adjusted the cuff. That was all it took to turn him into the guy I would follow into a ski lodge despite having no interest in skiing or compound fractures.
Jesus. It was a hat. I needed to get a grip.
He turned toward the mirror, then back to me. “Would your other brother like this one?”
“Absolutely not.” I pivoted toward the other colors before he could question my response.
There was no way I was buying Garrett a hat I thought looked hot on my boyfriend. I picked up a mustard yellow beanie and rubbed the material between my fingers.
Wait. Boyfriend?
Was Jensen my boyfriend? We hadn’t used that word. We’d established that we wanted more, but more covered a lot of territory. More fries. More kissing and orgasms.
And more with one meant more with three. I could have three boyfriends.
My fingers stopped moving over the knit. I’d barely managed singulars, and now I was considering a quantity that usually went on a multipack of premium underwear.
Except I wanted Jensen’s hand in mine. I wanted Cooper beside me in the kitchen and Luke making room for me on his couch. Not as separate fantasies I had to rank before someone demanded I choose.
Which seemed like a spectacular amount to lose.
What if I got used to having them around? What if I let myself get too attached and they decided I was too much of a confused pigeon with no idea where home was?
Jensen touched my arm, his fingers warm against the sliver of skin below my sleeve. “You okay?”
I blinked down at the hat. Mustard. Right. I was shopping, not submitting myself for an emotional audit beside the novelty headwear.
“Yup.” I tucked it under my arm with the unicorn beanie. “Garrett will love wearing the color of his favorite pastrami condiment on his head.”
Jensen didn’t smile. His eyes searched my face, and his mouth opened just as Luke appeared around the end of the display with Cooper behind him.
Cooper looked at Jensen’s head. “Are you buying that?”
Jensen looked at me instead of the mirror. “It’s up to her.”
My stomach flipped, the traitorous little shit. “Unfortunately.” I reached for his hand.
Cooper reached over and tugged the hat off. “I’ll buy this for you. It’s the first thing you’ve worn all year that doesn’t require sunglasses to look at.”
Jensen looked down at his green T-shirt that had the Well Hung logo on it. “That’s real funny coming from a man who doesn’t match his Christmas ties to his shirt colors.”
Luke steered me away from the potential fight. “Best to let them go at it over who dresses the worst.”
“Hey!” Both men sounded absolutely offended by Luke’s comment.
After paying for the hats and Jensen deciding on a hat with his nephew’s favorite football team’s logo, we hit three more calm stores before entering what could very easily be considered hell.
The toy store was chaos. Kids raced between aisles while parents were nowhere to be found. A toddler near the entrance screamed because his mother wouldn’t let him open a race car set right there on the floor.
We’d lingered in the other stores, but in this one we were on a mission. Luke had two nephews left on his list, Jensen wanted to investigate some toys before ordering them online, and Cooper disappeared.
That left me standing in the infant aisle wondering what the hell to buy a niece who had everything she’d ever need. She wouldn’t remember that her aunt got her a toy or an outfit at such a young age.
The farther I got down the aisle, the more I started to remember that presents were one of the reasons I disliked Christmas. There were way too many variables that might make the receiver unhappy with what they got.