Page 15
My mind raced, putting together all the clues I’d looked right over.
The hoodie. Number twenty-five. Jayden's hoodie.
The same person who'd been on her knees for me with my cock in her mouth and her cum on my lips.
Bri, my Rally Girl, was Briella DeLuca. Jayden DeLuca's little sister.
Fuck.
“Let's go.” Jay's voice cut through the static in my head. He'd turned, clocked me in the doorway, and was already reaching for his bag. He didn't see it. Didn't see me standing here with the floor disappearing under my feet. He pointed at the door. “KJ. Let's go. We're going to be late.”
He was already moving.
Bri held my gaze over the rim of her coffee mug.
“Stay put,” Jay said to her without looking back.
She said nothing, and Jay brushed past me through the doorway.
I stood there for one more second, holding her gaze across the kitchen, and all I could think was that she'd known. She'd walked into this house, and she’d known who I was, and she hadn't said a word.
“KJ,” Jay growled from the hallway now. “I'm leaving without you.”
I stood there staring at Bri for a long minute, and she flashed me a big innocent smile.
“You're Jay's sister,” I hissed under my breath. “And you didn't think you should tell me that.”
She shrugged. “Didn't seem relevant.”
Holy shit. I fucked my best friend's sister, my teammate's sister, and I did it while he was out looking for her.
I stepped forward and lowered my voice. “He can never know about this.”I turned and rushed out the door.
I was so fucking fucked…
7
KJ
I slid into the passenger seat and pulled the door shut behind me.
Jay started the engine before I'd even buckled, completely unaware that the person next to him was coming apart at the seams.
My brain wouldn't stop.
It kept cycling through everything—the party, the hoodie, the coffee table, the lake, the bedroom, the cuffs, the way she'd looked at me over the rim of that mug this morning with an expression that was either completely innocent or the most sophisticated act of psychological warfare I'd ever encountered. Every time it completed the loop, it started over again. Slightly worse. More detailed. More incriminating.
I'd slept with Jay's sister.
I'd slept with Jay's sister while Jay was out driving around town looking for her.
I'd put Jay's sister in handcuffs.
I'd claimed Jay's sister as my rally girl, put her on her knees, and…
I needed to stop.
I pressed the back of my skull against the headrest, fixed my eyes on the ceiling of the truck cab, and breathed through my nose. In. Out. Like a normal person. Like someone who had not just committed an act of complete and total bro code annihilation.