AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Heartless

Page 170

by Kassandra Marie Lopez

“I’d rather have you hate me for the rest of my life than keep getting this fucking silent treatment you’ve been giving me for the past five days.”

I swallowed hard.

“I don’t despise you.”

The words slipped out before I could stop them.

His expression changed. Some of the anger left his face, replaced by a fragile sort of hope that made my chest ache.

“Then what do you feel?”

I looked away.

I couldn’t answer him.

I wouldn’t.

Because if I said it out loud, I’d have to face what it meant.

“There you go again with the silent treatment.” Frustration sharpened his voice. “Why, Sophia? Why won’t you just tell me?”

“Because it’s easier!” I snapped.

The words hung between us.

Easier.

It was easier to hate him—or at least pretend I did—than admit that, after everything he’d done, I still loved him. Easier to keep him at a distance than risk letting him close enough to hurt me again.

Aristotle let out a bitter laugh.

“Easier for you, maybe. I’m fucking dying over here.”

His voice cracked on the last word, and for the first time, I saw just how much my silence had cost him.

“Fight me,” he demanded. “Scream at me. Tell me you hate me. Hurt me if you have to. Just give me something, Sophia. Anything. Just so I know you still feel something for me.”

His desperation settled over me like a weight.

I wanted to scream at him.

I wanted to tell him that he’d broken my heart, that he’d taken something precious from me and left me to carry the pain alone. I wanted to make him understand that his apology couldn’t erase the nights I’d spent crying or the future I’d mourned.

But beneath all that anger was a truth I’d been too afraid to face.

I still wanted him.

“You could have had me,” I whispered.

The crack in my voice betrayed me.

“All you ever had to do was be honest.”

He dragged a hand down his face. For the first time since he’d walked into the church, the fight seemed to drain out of him. His shoulders sagged, and the exhaustion etched into his features became impossible to ignore.

“I should’ve told you,” he said quietly. “About everything. About how I felt. About how it wasn’t just—”

He stopped, swallowing hard.