Page 118
I reach for a green felt shape covered in sequins.
“What is this?”
Tanner glances over. “Tree.”
“It is shaped like a triangle.”
“Same thing.”
I turn it over. CALEB is written across the back in faded black marker, the letters large and uneven.
“You made this.”
“Third grade, maybe.”
“And you kept it.”
“Ma kept it.”
I look down into the bin again. There are years in it.
A wooden hockey skate with his name painted across the blade. A photograph of a much younger Tanner grinning through a gap in his front teeth inside a red construction-paper frame. A ceramic snowman missing part of its scarf. Several battered glass ornaments that have clearly survived many Christmases.
I pick up another handmade ornament, this one a lopsided star covered in gold glitter.
“Sienna?”
“Yeah. Did the glitter give it away?”
I turn it over and find SIENNA written in purple marker. “It was an easy tell.”
“She was six.”
“You remember?”
He gives me a look as if this is an odd question. “Of course I remember.”
I set the star down more carefully than I picked it up. Tanner has already moved on, untangling a string of lights with the concentration of a man defusing something.
I go through the rest of the box more slowly.
Nothing matches. Not the colors, not the materials, not even the decades. There is no organizing principle beyond the fact that someone once made it, bought it, or loved it enough to wrap it in paper and put it away for another year.
At my parents’ house, Christmas arrives in crates.
The florist comes the week after Thanksgiving. The trees are selected in advance, usually three of them, and the decorations change according to whatever Mother has decided that year. Silver and white. Burgundy and gold. Once, an unfortunate period involving peacock feathers.
By the time we see the trees, they are finished. Perfect.
I pick up Tanner’s crooked felt tree again. “Did you decorate when you were little?”
He glances up from the lights. “Of course. You?”
“Our trees were usually done for us.”
“By whom?”
I shrug. “People.”