AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Arsonist’s Lullaby

Page 5

by Elizabeth Barone

I should’ve made the joke about the cat. I’ll never get an opening like that again.

“The Fishers will ride with you, then get any girls out while you’re doing the return,” Vaughn continues, and I realize he’s been talking.

I should pay attention. Tomorrow’s run’s a big one. I might never get another chance to be around Lucy, though. Though I can’t blame her, she’s not a fan of the club. Tonight’s the first time I’ve ever seen her in the Mermaid. It’s now or never. I start toward her.

She stands, draping her cardigan over one arm and grabbing her bag. Olivia hops up and reaches over the bar to hug her goodbye. The closer Lucy gets to the door, the farther she gets from me, and the slower I move. She slips into the parking lot, leaving me standing in the middle of the floor washed in neon lights.

Vaughn claps my shoulder. “Burners will be in your mailbox in the morning. I gotta take over bar back so Cliff can cover the door. You good here?”

I nod, dazed, disappointed in myself for letting the moment slip through my fingers.

I’ll see her again. It’s a matter of time. When I do, I’ll say hello.

2

Lucy

There’s no way this is legal. It’s my first thought as I pull in front of the shop where I’m supposed to pick up a refurbished stroller and car seat system. By all accounts, the Main Street storefront is empty. Dark windows stained with dust face the street, and I’m the only car parallel parked out front. I knew it seemed odd that a children’s thrift shop would be in Woodbury, of all places—a town where there are more antique and health food stores than people. Around here, moms buy their travel systems new on Prime. Plus, I’m pretty sure car seat regulations don’t even allow for “refurbishing,” or whatever it is this shop does. But I’m desperate.

I did it to myself. I could be one of those suburban moms with the latest, most expensive baby gadgets if I hadn’t broken up with my baby daddy when he proposed. I’m certifiably insane for even thinking of leaving a man who throws money at every problem with barely a thought. The thing is, I think he saw me as a problem, or he would eventually, if I married him. I didn’t want to be his trailer park teacher turned trad-wife, even if it came with a perfect white SUV to drive around our perfect five kids—I didn’t want to be a mom. I became a teacher to give kids like me a safe space from their monsters, to keep kids like my cousin Cliff out of prison. When Benjamin proposed, I knew if I said yes, next he’d pressure me into having his baby, and soon after, quit my job. He’d tell me what to wear, which PTA moms to befriend, and how to spend my “allowance.” It took me seven years to figure out he’s not what I want, and once I did, the relief was immediate.

So of course, a few weeks after I said no, a pregnancy test said yes.

I don’t want my baby to grow up in the shadow of my addict parents, both likely narcissists. I barely made it out of childhood, and poverty was the least of my traumas. I don’t want her to grow up under Benjamin’s thumb, either. I’d rather we be poor and free.

I need that travel system because it converts from a car seat to a stroller, is lightweight, and foolproof enough that I could do it all myself. That overpriced brand is actually a beacon of freedom, a way to raise a baby I didn’t plan for in the environment of my choice. Mine.

The place is probably closed, anyway. All I have to do is try the door, admit defeat, and get back in my car. Easy. Then I can go back to doomscrolling through more fake secondhand baby paraphernalia in the comfort of AC. Pregnancy’s got me sweating in places I never knew I could, and doesn’t play well with the late summer heatwave we’re in. When I turn the knob and push the door, it opens with a long, dusty creak.

The shop is even emptier than it looked from the street, and worse, there’s no AC. A single, brand new travel system sits in the middle of the small store, still unopened. Part of me is relieved. It fell off a truck, much like most of the things from my childhood: chicken cutlets, satellite cable, my adopted sister Olivia. At least I know it’ll be safe for my baby.

“Hello?” I run a finger over the box, leaving a trail in the dust. The factory seal is unbroken, the box isn’t even dented. I came with exactly enough cash, so this should be quick. I won’t even have to tell Olivia or Cliff how I got something so expensive. I’ll wrap it and pretend someone from work bought it for my shower.

Sweat drips between my tits, pooling under them, and my sundress sticks to me. “Hello!” I call again, louder.

“I’m coming,” a man replies, his accent almost Connecticut, the syllables lilting kinda like the actors’ do in the Norwegian TV show I got hooked on a few years back. A man covered in tattoos strolls out of the back, a cigarette clamped between his teeth. He’d be hot without the cancer stick. He rakes his dirty blond hair streaked with silver and red back from a face sculpted with high cheekbones. His jawline’s probably just as sharp, but it’s covered in beard.

I look pointedly at the cigarette, down at the small yet heavy watermelon I’m hauling around, and back at him.

“S-sorry.” He drops the butt onto the floor and grinds it out with a steel-toed boot, staring at me with baby blues. “You’re not...” He trails off and rubs his beard, those eyes drinking me in. “I know you,” he says, a warm smile brushing his lips like he’s happy to see me.

I should be alarmed. My pulse quickens, and a fluttering flickers low inside me, and it’s not fear. It’s hormones. I’ve officially reached the horny stage of pregnancy, and it’s insatiable. Doesn’t matter which toy or hand I use. The second I come, my body demands more, now, again.

No one ever looks at me the way he is, pupils dilated, and it shoots straight to my clit.

“You know me...?” I prod. I don’t recognize him, so I don’t think he’s a parent of one of my first graders. I’d remember the way his cut-off Pink Floyd tee clings to all that lean, tattooed muscle.

Hello, daddy.

“You’re Cliff and Olivia’s Lucy,” he says. “I’ve seen you in the bar. The Wet Mermaid?”

“You’re a River Reaper.” I should be concerned that he knows my face and name, but every biker in the club probably knows more about me than I do any of them. We share history.

At least now I can stare at him as long as I want. I assess lips that, even though they’re partially hidden under a mustache needing a trim, look soft and kissable. I should recognize him; I’m in the Mermaid more than I’d like. I stop in for a few minutes here and there, say hi to Olivia and Cliff when they’re working, and then I get out of there. It reminds me too much of standing behind my parents while the bartender slipped them a baggie of coke with their shots.

“Stixx,” he supplies with a wry smile.

I’d definitely remember that name. “Lucy,” I say, even though he already knows. I hold out a hand, and surprise alights on his face for a moment. He grips it in warm tattooed fingers, heat spreading through me. I think he feels it too, because his eyes widen and he smiles.