AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

A Reindeer Ex for Christmas

Page 13

by Noelle Drake

“Theo…” Jack began.

Theo raised a hand to stop him. “By the time you started sending me letters, I was dating someone, and I thought things were going to work out. It wasn’t everything I’d dreamt of, but for the first time in a long time, it was someone who wanted me more than I wanted them. So I shelved your letters after reading them. I hoped you, too, had someone who loved you more than you loved them, because that would mean you were also trying to fill a void. But the thing is, I also dreaded it. Every time I opened a letter, my heart stopped because I was scared you’d do it: mention someone who wasn’t me. But you never did.”

“Then you saw me at the funeral.” Jack had always been good at putting the pieces together. This time was no different.

“Then I saw you at the funeral,” Theo confirmed. “And then you stopped sending letters. I couldn’t even blame you. I deserved it, and it broke me. Seeing you so in love with someone who wasn’t me. I was at your parents’ fucking funeral, and I was thinking about how you weren’t with me.”

The tears came unexpectedly. One second, Theo’s face was dry and the next thing he knew, he was sucking up snot. Jack didn’t move to comfort him, for which Theo was grateful. He couldn’t take Jack’s kindness just yet.

“It doesn’t get more selfish than that, does it?”

“Selflessness was never your biggest strength,” Jack deadpanned.

“Yeah.” Theo sniffed, wiping his face with the sleeve of Jack’s shirt. “I wouldn’t blame you if you hated me.”

Jack said nothing, and the silence stretched on for longer than Theo could stand. Finally, Jack stood up and walked slowly towards him. He stretched his arms out and pulled Theo into a gentle embrace. His arms were solid and warm, and Theo melted right into him. His hands rubbed circles into Theo’s back. His totally dignified tears turned into sobbing, and Theo could feel that he was soaking Jack’s chest.

Being folded into Jack like this was familiar, and the steady increase of his heartbeat was like music to his ears. When Jack pulled away, his green eyes were misty.

“I could never hate you,” he whispered.

“I made things harder,” Theo said through his tears. “You were already going through so much, and then I showed up and disappeared like an asshole without even explaining myself. I hated so much about myself back then and I showed the worst side of myself every chance I got.”

“That’s what happens when you run from what you want, Theo.”

Jack leaned down and pressed his nose to Theo’s. His shiny green eyes stared hard into Theo’s brown ones. For a moment, they stayed like that, embracing each other, unwilling to let go. Theo watched Jack’s furrowed brow, the anxiety in his chest blooming.

“Jack, I—-”

His words died in his mouth when for the first time in twenty years, Jack’s lips met his.

At first, it was a soft brush of their lips, a gentle touch Theo didn’t see coming. Then, Jack’s hand trailed up the side of Theo’s neck, his fingers knotting in his soft curls, brushing the nape of his neck as he pulled him closer.

Of course, Theo had been kissed plenty in LA. But this was the first time in a long time that a kiss had felt like home. Jack cupped his face and warmth spread over Theo. The moment was honest and open, the way Jack did everything. He tasted familiar, like the long summer nights when he’d laid wrapped in his arms, eyes heavy, sleep overtaking him.

But Theo wasn’t being lulled to sleep now. In fact, he’d never been more awake.

At first, Theo’s lips barely moved. He was shocked. Was Jack seriously kissing him after everything he’d said? After all the ways he’d admitted to hurting both of them?

It was as if Jack had read his mind. He tightened his grip on Theo’s hair and drew him closer, seizing him fully. The spark that shot through Theo spread from his lips to his heart. It made his toes curl with need.

This wasn’t his hallucination in the shower. This was real. He wanted to do something.

He needed to do something.

Theo buried his fingers in Jack’s thick hair, his nails scraping over his scalp in an instinctive and natural way. After all these years, he still knew the right amount of pressure needed to make Jack whine.

Deep from Jack’s throat came his reward and Theo deepened the kiss, tilting his head sideways as his lips parted underneath Jack’s. They kissed desperately, neither of them worrying about the lack of oxygen, both more focused on filling the space between them with nothing but their rough moans and the soft sound of their tongues dancing in sync.

Theo wasn’t sure who broke the kiss first, but his body was on fire. His feet were made of gelatin. His brain was floating in a pool of desire.

Jack gazed down at him with swollen pink lips, the tip of his nose scarlet red. His hair was tousled, and his green eyes were wide with unwavering intensity. Before Theo could pull away, Jack’s arms wrapped tight around his waist and he pressed him closer until their bodies seemed as one.

Theo gulped down a ragged breath. “I haven’t been kissed like that in years,” he admitted shyly.

For a moment, Jack was silent. Then, his lips spread into a wide grin.

“Well.” His voice was a husky rasp that sent shivers down Theo’s spine. “I also haven’t kissed anyone like that in years, so we’re fairly matched.”