AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

A Reindeer Ex for Christmas

Page 16

by Noelle Drake

Theo broke eye contact first. His ears were so hot and he wished he was having this conversation without a witness. “I’m in Lake Falls. Safe and sound as they say. But listen, I crashed the rental car, and—”

“Did you call the police?” His dad asked.

Theo bit his lip. The thought of calling the cops had not crossed his mind. He knew it was going to bite him in the ass later, but he honestly didn’t care.

“Nevermind the car, son.” His dad said. “You’re safe. And…hang on a second. Did you say you’re with your Claus boy?”

Nevermind the car? “Yes,” Theo replied with a sigh. Did no one care about his goddamn car accident? “I’m with Jack.”

“You’re alone with the Claus boy?” His dad’s voice was very low as he repeated the question.

“Yes, Dad.”

“Listen, son.” His dad’s voice was suddenly very serious. “It’s Christmas Eve, you know. We made a lot of food for your return, and we want to see you, but…”

“But?” Why the hell was there a but?

“You know he’s single…” Samuel informed him.

“I know.” Theo’s voice was low as he replied.

“He won’t be getting married anytime soon.”

“You know, he said the same thing.” Theo couldn’t help but laugh.

“I’m sure he did.” Theo heard a breathy laugh from his dad. “Snow plows are low on staff this year, and you know they don’t come this far out until the day after Christmas, so it’s probably safest to stay put. Your mom thinks the same.”

“Alright, I’ll see you both tomorrow.”

On the other end of the line, Samuel Pine’s exhale was very soft. He sounded like the dad Theo had had all those years ago, when he and Jack had first started dating and everything was new and different from the days of their friendship. No longer were they boys chasing each other in the tall summer grass, or throwing snowballs in the winter.

“I’m sure it’s alright with your Ma.”

The response was the same one he’d heard for so many years, and Theo’s eyes watered.

Deja vu was a hell of a thing.

Chapter 8

Dinner was a stir fry Jack threw together during Theo’s phone call with his parents. They sat next to each other at the large dining table, forks scraping against the plates as they ate in silence.

“This is really good.” Theo didn’t know what else to say. The interruption of his call had made him lose his nerve.

Had they actually kissed? Or had that been another hallucination?

“Do you feel better after getting all that out?” Jack’s question pulled him out of his head. His face was full of intensity.

Theo chewed thoughtfully. He never thought he’d get a chance to share his feelings like that. He was sitting in Jack’s family home for the first time in two decades, eating a meal Jack had cooked for him, wearing clothes Jack had gathered for him. God. Was he lucky enough for a second chance at this?

“Do you feel better?” He asked Jack. He didn’t want to focus on his feelings alone. He was taking everything so seriously, and he didn’t want to be the only one doing that. If he was wrong, it was better to find out now, rather than after he left and convinced himself he and Jack had a future together.

“I forgave you a long time ago, Theo,” Jack said. “It’s a matter of you forgiving yourself.”

“I caused you a lot of pain, Jack.”

“Yeah. You did. And it took me a long time to heal from it,” he told Theo. “I’m not fully healed, and obviously, things won’t ever be the same. But I like to think forgiving someone you love is worth it every time.”

Theo thought about it for a second.