Page 7
Theo thought back to that time. Even though all nine of the Claus kids were well into their adult years, Mr. and Mrs. Claus still maintained their gifting traditions. Eight years ago, on their way back home from deliveries, their car had been struck by a truck skidding on the ice and they died instantly.
Theo had heard about the deaths from his parents during one of their monthly phone calls. His heart had dropped at the news, but he didn’t know what he was supposed to do. Show up to the funeral after years of avoiding Jack? Send him a letter wishing him well after ignoring all the letters he’d mailed to the Pine house? In the early nineties, email wasn’t as popular as they were now, so by the time Theo sat down to actually pour his feelings out on paper, he’d talked himself out of it.
He hadn’t sent a letter, but he had attended the funeral. He sat in the back with shaky hands, wiping the sweat off his brow during the entire ceremony. When Jack read the eulogy, Theo had cried along with the other attendees, and when it came time for the viewing, he’d gone up with his hands behind his back. He didn’t know what to say—he’d never seen a dead person before.
Mr. and Mrs. Claus had been adorned in beautifully tailored clothes and expensive jewelry, but he could barely remember anything else, especially since he’d run away the second he could. He didn’t want to face Jack, who at the time was recently married. Naturally, he’d brought his beautiful banshee wife to the funeral, and she’d stood there, right next to him, with eyes that sparkled with earnest tears and a voice that sounded angelic when she read her own note.
He couldn’t stand it.
He didn’t want to have to speak to Jack and congratulate him on his wife while extending sympathy for his loss. He didn’t know how to say he was sorry about all the letters he’d read but never responded to. So instead, he did what he always did: he ran away.
He didn’t want to have to speak to Jack and congratulate him on his wife. He didn’t know how to say he was sorry about all the letters he’d read but never responded to. So instead, he did what he always did: he ran away. He’d muttered a lie to his parents about needing to be back at work immediately. He’d spent the entire drive to the Burlington airport blinded by heavy tears, white knuckling the steering wheel as he came to terms with all the things he’d lost.
Now, faced with everything he’d never said and every way he’d hurt Jack, he was full of shame. Having to sit in the guilt while he was being taken care of only made him feel worse.
How could he do that to the man he’d called his best friend for most of his life? To the man he’d let see everything? To the man who, even after all these years, still made his heart skyrocket?
“I’m sorry.” Theo took another sip. The hot cocoa was the perfect temperature, and it was incredibly sweet, just the way he liked it.
“That might’ve been enough eight years ago,” Jack responded.
“I know.”
Jack was silent.
Theo’s eyes scanned the room and he noticed how different everything was. He’d spent his childhood running around this house with Jack and his siblings, wishing that he had even one of his own to experience the traditions with. As an only child, Theo had always been jealous of how close Jack and his siblings were, and he often wondered how different his life would be if his parents had decided to have another child. He wished he’d been more thankful for the easy years where he felt like a part of something big.
He wished he’d been more thankful for a lot of things.
The walls of the house were the same light tan color, but the lack of Christmas decorations felt odd. For the first time, he noticed the collection of moving boxes in the corner of the room and he held his breath.
“A-are you selling the house?”
He couldn’t believe his suspicion had been right. The Claus family was selling the house right when Theo was moving back. It was a hell of his own making, but he couldn’t help but feel withered.
“No.” Jack’s response was low, almost under his breath. “I’ve lived here on and off for years, but I’m doing some renovations before I move in permanently.”
“Your wife didn’t seem like the kind of person who’d want to live in the middle of nowhere.” He hadn’t meant to sound so bitter, but he’d never forgotten the beautiful woman who had held Jack so tight at the funeral. She seemed like someone who belonged in a big city, not a small rural town in the middle of Vermont.
But maybe he was wrong. After all, Mrs. Claus had seemed like that kind of woman, and she’d been anything but. In any case, he didn’t have a right to think about that. He was the one who’d let Jack go in the first place.
“I think you need a shower.” Jack stood up abruptly and his tone threw Theo off. Jack’s tone was off, but Theo couldn’t put his finger on it.
Had his comment about Jack’s wife been that offensive?
He wanted to push for an answer, but taking a hot shower sounded heavenly.
“That sounds perfect—” Instantly, Theo’s shoulders fell. “—shit. Do you have anything for me to wear?”
Theo was aware that he was making things more difficult for Jack, but he couldn’t help it. He was entirely his hands. The thought made heat travel through his body, and he fought to control his breathing. This was not the time. Jack was married. Maybe was probably one of those men who didn’t wear a ring. That was what a lot of modern couples did.
“I probably do,” Jack replied. “I’ve been digging up some of my clothes from college. I’m sure there’s something in those piles that’ll fit.”
Theo swallowed the lump in his throat. He remembered snowy days like this, watching the snowstorm raging on the other side of the window, hot chocolate in his hands as he snuggled safely into the warmth of the inside and Jack’s thick, solid form.
“I’ve been doing some work on the house, so you’ll have to use my bathroom, if that’s fine.”
Theo nodded. He tried not to think about all the singular statements Jack was making and instead filled his mind with the fact that he was there, being helped by someone he’d sooner expect to let him freeze to death. Had the situation been switched, Theo wasn’t sure he’d have been as generous as Jack was being.